Fort Myers Restaurant Guide
Fort Myers Italian Restaurant Reviews
Welcome to our Fort Myers Italian restaurant reviews guide where you'll find top restaurants off the beaten path, both locally owned and chain. In fact, some of the best restaurants in the Fort Myers just might be the little mom and pop operations flying under the radar. For some of the best picks in Fort Myers, you've come to the right place.
Our Fort Myers restaurant reviews guide can help you make sense of the thousands of options out there. Happy eating!
Also check out our Best Restaurants in Fort Myers 2025 Guide
(01/12/2018)
This Place was very good, but it has been closed for years. Too bad they did not remove this page.
ordered ffor carry out---picked up order, order incorrect, and pd extra for it!!! called said they would delive. gave address and delivered to wrong place and never got food that i paid extra for. we are a business and will not call them again.
We've been frequenting this restaurant and are always pleased with the menu selections and quality of food. I think they make their own breads and they are fabulous on burgers, french dip, etc. Tonight we had pizza and I just wanted to write about it. (I needed the phone number so I thought I'd writ...
This guy does not honor his gift certificates. Do not buy them
Food was mixed - some good and some not so good but it was a long wait for all food. Ambience was just okay - lot of dirty tables were left uncleaned when we were there. Wait Staff - just one waitress who was not very pleased to be waiting tables - she was quite rude to us and other customers Fina...
Very disappointing dining expereince!! RUDE Service & slow getting food out after you order. Minerva's has only 1 rude and condescending waitress & 1 cook. The food was okay but not worth the 50 minute wait and the rude treatment. She treated other people rudely too, not just us. Maybe Minerva shou...
Met the rudest waitress ever, Jenn! Very condescending to us and to other diners sitting nearby. (We couldn't help but hear the rude things she said to them also). Who wants to go back to this place when you are treated like dirt? Certainly nobody I know! The food was ok but somewhat on the pri...
(02/02/2011)
Mark, what do you have against White Zin? was in tonight and not only did you not have White Zin but Riesling was by the bottle only. what is up?
First: Food was tasty. Second: Service was verrrrrrry slooooow Third: Portions were very small Fourth: prices were high = $40.00 for 2 fish dinners
My family and I have been eating at Nino's for about 3 years since we bought a home in Fort Myers. We are from New York and have to say it is just like being home. The food and the ambience are wonderfull. Graziano and the staff always take time to say hello. The best Italian food in Fort Myers.
We've been eating at Nino's for at least 15 years. NEVER have we had a bad meal, bad service or unclean place settings. As a REALTOR, when I'm asked about places to eat. I always recommend Nino's first.
My friends, husband and I happened upon this restaurant on the way home from our IsXperia Convention in Sanibel. Can't say enough about the food not to mention how reasonable it was. We enjoyed everything and the friendliness and service of the staff was commendable. Would definitely stop by again...
best NY style pizza ive had. and very consistent. i'm from Huntington Long Island by the way.
My friends and I were at Cibo's on Feb. 18 prior to going to the Barbara Mann. We had a reservation and were seated immediately. We had to wait for our server who we all felt was lacking. The restaurant, while busy, was not that busy. Our server never brought bread nor did she refill water glass...
(02/20/2010)
There were 6 of us for dinner, 3 meals came out cold, had to be reheated and in the microwave no less so my sauce was burnt and dry. None of us were really pleased with our meals. mediocore at best not worth the prices.
Best Pizza in the Estero area! True New York Pizza, loved the garlic knots. Had a cannoli, fresh and homemade. I'm going back.
Really good pizza- best I've had in the area. The ambiance is nice- not fancy though. I will definitely be back- I'll make it my "regular" spot for a good quick Italian dinner.
excellent food, excellent service, definitely going to visit again soon!
if you haven't tried LaMotta's Italian restaurant you've got to go and try it. The food is made fresh. Ee started with the antipasti salad for 2 and we ordered pizza. Justust like in NY! Then we also tried the tour of Sicily - the best - and for dessert the cannoli. If we can't make it there we can...
Wow! I felt like i was at my grandmothers house the food at LaMotta's was the best and I wish that I found this place a long time ago. If you go try the seafood called the posilipo the best and leave room for the rum cake. I'll be back this week with the rest of my family for more great Italian food