follow us on twitter    Get ActiveDiner on the iPhone

Reviews By Cuisine

All Reviews (104)
American (4)
American Traditional (6)
Cheesesteaks (1)
Chicken (1)
Chinese (5)
Continental (1)
Diner (7)
French (1)
Indian (10)
Indian/Pakistan (4)
Italian (33)
Japanese (6)
Korean (4)
Latin (2)
Mediterranean (3)
Middle Eastern (3)
New American (1)
Pakistani (6)
Pizzeria (11)
Seafood (3)
Spanish (2)
Steak House (1)
Sushi Bar (1)

Other City Reviews

Briarcliff Manor
Cold Spring
Cortlandt Manor
Dobbs Ferry
East Elmhurst
Forest Hills
Fresh Meadows
Glen Oaks
Howard Beach
Jackson Heights
Jefferson Valley

Staten Island Restaurant Reviews

Staten Island  restaurant reviews photo

Welcome to our Staten Island restaurant reviews guide where you'll find top restaurants off the beaten path, both locally owned and chain. In fact, some of the best restaurants in the Staten Island just might be the little mom and pop operations flying under the radar. For some of the best picks in Staten Island, you've come to the right place.

Our Staten Island restaurant reviews guide can help you make sense of the thousands of options out there. Happy eating!

Also check out our Best Restaurants in Staten Island 2016 Guide

Sort By:  Latest Reviews | Rating | A-Z  
Displaying 1 - 20 of 104


 2 star(s)  (01/13/2013)
“Disappointing. Quality of food below Average. Value below average. Overpriced yet friendly customer service.”

Napoli Pizza

 3 star(s)  (03/28/2011)
“i absolutley LOVE napoli pizza and even their pasta is delicious but their service is horrible. so i just use to order oline with them to not have to deal witht hem messing up my order on the phone and everything gets delivered with no complaints :)”

Portobello Cafe

 4 star(s)  (03/24/2011)
“Let me start by saying that for years I felt this was a wonderful restaurant, the food is well prepared, hearty portions, and the ambience is casually elegant. However, there are so many rules & regulations governing the midweek special pricing, they now have a full page printout detailing them. And... ”

Vola Kitchen & Bar

 5 star(s)  (01/11/2011)
“Just went there last night for dinner and drinks….the look of Vola is really nice…I really liked the atmosphere! The food was so tasty and a really large menu with a lot of selections…GREAT drinks from the bar and the desserts were sooo good….I had the Chicken Rollatini--very very good and I had th... ”

Shaggy's Cheesesteaks

 5 star(s)  (01/10/2011)

Portobello Cafe

 3 star(s)  (11/12/2010)
“the food portion is getting smaller,from the salad for two,to dinner the buy 1 get 1.even the glass of wine is small for the price”

Portobello Cafe

 5 star(s)  (09/05/2010)
“My wife and I have been eating here since Adam opened.The food is usually very good but as any other places can have an off night. We eat here at least twice a month the prices on the 2 for 1 can't be beat.The only problem that we have is the price of drinks is never the same prices depend on the ba... ”

Woodrow Diner

 5 star(s)  (06/27/2010)
“Although the name says "Diner," it is far from a diner. The food and ambiance are more like a wonderful restaurant. The food is exceptionally good. I would usually never order Italian food in anything other than an Italian Restaurant, however, Woodrow's chefs prepare outstanding Italian entrees. W... ”

Portobello Cafe

 5 star(s)  (01/22/2010)
“I am thoroughly surprised to read all of these poor reviews! I have been going to this restaurant for years with my family and last night we went again, but this time (for the first time in her life) my daughter, who is almost 4 yrs old, ate a meal prepared by someone other than my family. She has... ”

Tokyo Sushi Japanese

 5 star(s)  (11/24/2009)
“Tokyo has the freshest sushi I can always count on. I've traveled a lot and tried many fine sushi restaurants, but this one is always my favorite by far. The price is very reasonable, yet the quality of food is just remarkable. If you are a true connoisseur of sushi, you know you can rarely find wha... ”

Tokyo Sushi Japanese

 5 star(s)  (11/24/2009)
“Tokyo has the freshest sushi I can always count on. I've traveled a lot and tried many fine sushi restaurants, but this one is always my favorite by far. The price is very reasonable, yet the quality of food is just remarkable. If you are a true connoisseur of sushi, you know you can rarely find wha... ”

Luigino Restaurant

 4 star(s)  (11/09/2009)
“I had Sunday dinner there with my family (6) people all together. This place has been here a very long time with faithful regulars. It's an old school experience with food and service that is good. The fried calamari and clams oreganato were delicious. When I asked if they can make a simple pasta bo... ”

Aka Sushi Japanese Restaurant

 5 star(s)  (11/05/2009)
“I'm not sure what the name implies but the food is superb. I took my son the 9 year old sushi connoisseur and my 4 year old daughter to dinner. They offer a unique assortment of sushi rolls and appetizers that would appeal to the most discriminating appetite. The atmosphere is warm and the service k... ”


 4 star(s)  (10/10/2009)
“Their French Fries are THE best I've ever had”

Portobello Cafe

 2 star(s)  (10/09/2009)
“By far one of the most rudest and obnoxious experiences ive ever dealt with in my life, First lets start with the positive big portions and a good value, But lets think about that how can all this food be so cheap quality sub par i dont even think my veal was veal, tasted more like pork if you ask ... ”


 4 star(s)  (09/29/2009)
“I attended my niece's confirmation dinner on Sat afternoon. The only other time I was there was for a surprise B-Day party. The food is good, but the service superceeded anything on this Island. The portions should be bigger and prices lower. I don't beleive 30 per person extra for an open bar is pr... ”


 4 star(s)  (09/28/2009)
“I attended a confirmation dinner there on Sat afternoon. Prior to this I was only there one other time for a family party. The place is beautiful and tastefully decorated. I do have a problem with the prices (30.00 per person extra for an open bar and 100 extra for valet parking). The service superc... ”

Portobello Cafe

 4 star(s)  (09/24/2009)
“My family and I ate their last night. What a pleasant experience. The value on the 2 for 1 is great and the food and service outstanding. It's nice to see a place packed on a week night. Obviously they know what they are doing they are around a long time. Please keep it up.”

The Lake Club

 5 star(s)  (09/23/2009)
“I would recommend the Lake Club. The food & service was outstanding. I was a guess at a party Sept 22,2009 everyone was so surpise with the new improvements. it is a lovely place to dine. To the Owners Keep up the great work Keep up the great work and you will be there for years”

D & B Doubles Chinese Kitchen

 4 star(s)  (08/28/2009)
“This is my favorite neighborhood Chinese restaurant of all time. Their consistently tasty menu selections, boosted by attractive, friendly and engaging hostesses are a boon to St. George take-out dining.”

Read more Staten Island restaurant reviews >>