Staten Island Restaurant Guide
Staten Island italian Restaurant Reviews
Welcome to our Staten Island italian restaurant reviews guide where you'll find top restaurants off the beaten path, both locally owned and chain. In fact, some of the best restaurants in the Staten Island just might be the little mom and pop operations flying under the radar. For some of the best picks in Staten Island, you've come to the right place.
Our Staten Island restaurant reviews guide can help you make sense of the thousands of options out there. Happy eating!
Also check out our Best Restaurants in Staten Island 2025 Guide
Displaying 21 - 39 of 39
Sort By:
Latest Reviews
| Rating | A-Z
the food portion is getting smaller,from the salad for two,to dinner the buy 1 get 1.even the glass of wine is small for the price
Bario's is a local Pizza Parlor in a small overcrowded strip of stores in Heatland Village. It was recently redecorated and hundreds of photos that once grace it's walls were removed. It is much more subdued now, done in quieter tans and browns, hopefully to cater to a less noisier and slightly ol...
Mediocre dining experience at best. Don't bother with delivery. I live 2 blocks away, have ordered from this place a couple of times. Each time delivery took close to an hour and the Pizza was cold and undercooked.
DINING AT PORTOBELLO WAS A MONTHLY RITUAL FOR MY FRIENDS AND I FOR THE PAST FEW YEARS. THE QUALITY OF FOOD HAS DETERIORATED. THE 'DA BEST CHICKEN PARM' WAS HORRIBLE. THE MANAGEMENT LOUDLY AND PUBLICALLY BERATED A WAITER ON THE OPEN FLOOR UPSETTING MANY PATRONS. ALSO ON ANOTHER OCCASSION, DURING A...
By far one of the most rudest and obnoxious experiences ive ever dealt with in my life, First lets start with the positive big portions and a good value, But lets think about that how can all this food be so cheap quality sub par i dont even think my veal was veal, tasted more like pork if you ask ...
I live nearby and went for lunch with my daughter. She said her meal was good but I ordered chicken & shrimp scampi lunch special and it was awful. Not only were the shrimp & chicken very spicey (tasted like they had been dipped in red hot sauce, didn't taste garlic so it certainly didn't taste lik...
Went to this restaurant over a year ago and it was nice. Wen't back again about 4 weeks ago and it just wasn't the same. The food was nothing to write home about. The on the way out I asked one of the folks who worked there if they had changed owners. The guy said no they just changed chefs. Wow, wh...
very disappointed in the appetizer which was hot antipasto for two not enough on the plate and the shrimps were very tiny so was the eggplant ,mushrooms and clams for the money.My entree was filetmignon and very very thin cut .Also the vegetables were frozen not fresh. My plate was served to me luk...
usually like dimly lit restaurants but pretty sure this was dark because it was dirty. went there as a guest at a birthday party, felt sorry for the host who paid. the waitress was the worst i've experienced, what little time she was at our table,bossy and lazy. there was no discerning that what i w...
Where do I start? First off, I haven't been to Buona Pasta since the new owner took over. Which was over 2 years ago. My family and I used to go all the time, just for dinner during the week or for holiday dinners like Thanksgiving and Christmas Eve. I made reservations a month in advance, due to i...
Went Saturday evening 11/3/07. The appetizer was excellent. The main courses were terrible. I ordered the stuffed pork chop, it was brought out burnt to crisp. I sent it back and the replacement had no flavor. There is no chef in this kitchen, only line cooks. My wife's fish, a special, was drowned ...
What a horrible expierience, my family and I were dining and while we were eating, seated near the entrance to the kitchen we overheard screaming and yelling. The profanity was absurd we later learned that it was the owner Ive never been so turned off to a place in my life. A bunch of Kids running a...
We ate there last week. 2 for 1 cash special. Service was very good, but a glass of seltzer was $2.50 with NO refills. The salad was terrible and the pasta tasted like sheetrock. It's a shame the city doesn't close it.
the food portion is getting smaller,from the salad for two,to dinner the buy 1 get 1.even the glass of wine is small for the price
First of all the food was just okay. Nothing to write home about. The restaurant was very dark so that you could hardly see what you were eating. The waiter spilled a soda on my daughter and had to move our table. When we got the bill there was absolutely no compensation for the inconvenience. ...
(06/19/2008)
my favorite place in staten island. kinda pricey but never lets you down. great for special occasions.
(02/26/2006)
yuck
(02/13/2007)
Have been a loyal customer for years and the new look of the place blows me away...Not only does it look great the new dinner menu cant be beat....As the Chef would say Da Best!!!!!
(11/09/2007)
obviously the last rater was competition from another local restaurnat. Portobello is excellent. Try for yourself. Go on a 2 for 1 so you don't spend that much to find out. You will love it.