Saint Augustine Restaurant Guide
Saint Augustine Restaurant Reviews
Welcome to our Saint Augustine restaurant reviews guide where you'll find top restaurants off the beaten path, both locally owned and chain. In fact, some of the best restaurants in the Saint Augustine just might be the little mom and pop operations flying under the radar. For some of the best picks in Saint Augustine, you've come to the right place.
Our Saint Augustine restaurant reviews guide can help you make sense of the thousands of options out there. Happy eating!
Also check out our Best Restaurants in Saint Augustine 2025 Guide
Displaying 1 - 20 of 58
Sort By:
Latest Reviews
| Rating | A-Z
Poor service ruined the dining experience. Queso was cold - sent it back and was good. Dinner arrived later - cold - no offer was made to make it right, so I gave up, paid my bill and left no tip. Food may have been good when fresh, but sat in the window too long. Upstairs dining seemed quite pop...
At first I was trying to be understanding since there was only two servers. I then realized that three tables that arrived after us had gotten their food and was now trying to pay for their order. I asked the hostess about our order and she said they were behind. I then asked the waitress after not ...
An excellent, though often overlooked eatery right in the heart of historic St. Augustine. The ambiance leaves something to be desired, booths and laminate tabletops, but the food is excellent, as is the service.
THE BEST BREAKFAST I HAVE EVER HAD! EVER! Its kind of small and plain inside but the food is unreal!
(06/14/2007)
After waiting 100 minutes to be seated (we were originally told 30 to 40 minutes untill a table would be ready and then kept getting told only twenty more minutes untill we were finally seated) we then waited 45 minutes to get our food. One individuals order was completly wrong, and the menu failed...
We went to Barnacle Bills on 9/14/09...my husband ordered the mahi grilled platter w/ baked potato and cucumber salad for sides. I ordered the fried flounder sandwich w/ fries for side. We both ordered Caesar salads. THAT IS WHAT WE ORDERED...HERE IS WHAT WE RECEIVED: My husband received a leathery...
I had read other reviews and decided to try. I had a bad feeling before I walked in the door, but decided to try anyway. Dirty outside, usually means dirty inside and this was the case. I was very disappointed with the choices for side items (buttered corn- out of a can, mandarin oranges - out of...
I really hate to be ignored, but that's what happened at first...we were seated and then nothing happened. However...once we got our food, it was good and plentiful. This isn't a tourist place...this is one that the locals patronize.
Since the other reviews are several years old I can only assume the restaurant has done a complete turnaround because my family loved it. I didn't want to go there because I assumed it was a family-type, fried-seafood place. And it was. But it was GREAT. It was very clean, the tables were far ap...
(01/02/2008)
I'm originally from N.Y.and moved to St.Augustine a short time ago. Fishing from the pier in Vilano we discovered Benito's Pizza,Wow! Finally a pizza that tasted like home in N.Y.C. It's the only thing I really missed from N.Y. and now we have the best of everything right here in sunny florida!
We eat her at least once or twice a month and throughly enjoy it. Benito does a great job. Meet him, you'll like him. :)
Excellent food for the price. Try to go on the night they have German food. It is authentic and delicious! (I heard the owner was born in Germany, so he knows how to prepare German food.) They have a pork chop dish that is served with a light curry sauce and sauteed apples that is delightful. I crav...
This restaurant was recommended by a local and I am very sorry we went. The table was dirty, and we had to sit outside because they would not let us sit (with our kids) inside ... well, except for this plastic bubbled room! There were only TWO kids menu options. My She Crap Soup was COLD and used...
On 03/15/09, a sunday. I decided to take my inlaws, wife and three kids to Caps for a late lunch. I called ahead and asked if the they had call ahead seating, and if woe could make the lunch menu. The very gratious waitstaff said no problem. as long as you are seated by 3:30pm. We arrived @ 2:4...
I visited Caps about a week ago I grew up in the area and I had been before but, it had been I guess 10 years maybe less . They have a great location and the view is great more so in the evening .So we decided to go for lunch . It was after a summer rain so it was very Humid we walked to ...
My husband and I stumbled onto this restaurant on our way home from St. Augustine. I was pleasantly suprised by the setting of this little place, tucked back off the main road. We enjoyed an evening of great food, service, and the view was even better sitting on the deck, watching the water roll b...
Imagine you have a big dock jutting out into the Intracoastal Waterway with the seating area a deck. Boats come in, dock, and eat. Your drive down and ulikely side road. And you can eat outside but under a canopy of multiple river oaks with branches 3 or 4 feet over your head. Unique. Lot of fun.
This restaurant had a very nice atmosphere and was very clean. The waiter was incompitant. We recieved our salads at the end of our meal and never recieved our rolls, I never even got a refil on my tea. I ordered a 3 seafood combination platter fried and the food was soggy in my plate, my husband o...
The food and atmosphere were extraordinary!!!
THIS PLACE IS HORRIBLE!! We got their flyer and decided to give them a try. OMG, what a terrible experience that was. First they delivered the WRONG item and what was supposed to be hot & spicy according to their menu, was bland and disgusting. Then, we called to ask them to please bring the correct...