get treated as royalty... they pile the food high... and is tastey and deliscious...
Every thing was good The crab legs was great
Had a gathering with friends we have not seen in years, we all found Portofino to be a wonderful dining experience. The ambience was lovely, very romantic and airy. The food was great as well as the attentive service. We all felt at home especially when the piano playe Michael filled all of our requ...
I was in this beautiful place last summer, I had de best food, especially the fry oysters... I can not understand why in such of beautiful place the bathrooms are not taking care of such as no locks on the doors and dirty looking...
The food is great and cheap for a restaurant, a hard deal to come by. It is small but has a nice setting inside. The waiters are friednly and are quick to seat you. There is a parking lot and also a small bar. The inside is dark with yellow lights. For the most part, its a great restaurant. Th...
Waiters are not very friendly. Small portions for your money. bathrooms are very unsanitary and the doors has no locks. The food is OK. Would not recommend this restaurant.
As a frequent diner on City Island, I know that C.I. is one of the best kept seafood dining areas in the NYC Metro Area. Portofino, although trying to compete with fine restaurants on City Island, needs a lot of help. The management just hasn't gotten the idea that a restaurant experience is a funct...
Service is so poor only 3 people understand english in the dinning room. The Italians have left and the Albanians don't seem to understand not only english but they also don"t understand service. Avoid this restaurant unless you want to be aggravated.
I JUST HAD THE WORST EXPERIENCE AT THIS RESTAURANT! SLOW SERVICE,RUDE MANAGER AND MY DAUGHTER FOUND A BUG IN HER FOOD!!! WE CALLED FOR THE MANAGER TO COME OVER SEVERAL TIMES, LETS JUST SAY I'M STILL WAITING FOR HIM TOO ARRIVE! NOW THE HEALTH DEPARTMENT WILL HEAR OF THIS!! JUST REALLY GROSS!!!
I have never met a more rude group of people then in this restaurant. They clearly do not know how to treat people. I felt so uncomfortable. I will never go back. Artie's puts you guys to shame... NEVER AGAIN....
We had a TERRIBLE experience at this restaurant, topped off by my six year old son being served chicken that was COMPLETELY raw and would have made him very ill. Although it was practically empty, it took ten minutes for anyone to bring us a menu, over an hour for our food to come, and then, of cou...
Stay away! Far away! I have never done this - but I couldn't wait to come home to the computer and blast where ever I can print how terrible our experience was this evening at Portofino on City Island. We were a group of 6. We were seated at 7 but the balance of our group didn't arrive till 7:30. Th...
Worst oxtail I have ever had. Taste nothing like Caribbean food should taste. It taste like straight gravy master soooooo disappointed. I ordered oxtail from there about a year ago and it was 100% better they are moving backwards
A major disappointment! The steak was very very thin and the tail was small.
During my couple years of dining at Portofino's, I always remembered the exquisite food, good SERVICE a nd amazing atmosphere. Afteryears of eating here, the service got worse the Food is not the same, I missthe homemade desserts, like the beautiful tiramisu, chocolate soufle, Apple tart, etc, the ...