New York Restaurant Guide

Gotham Bar And Grill
4.3 stars (1 ratings)

(212) 620-4020

12 E 12th St, New York, NY 10003

View Map

Looking for deals near here?

See Restaurant.com gift certificates for restaurants in 10003.

Browse Local Deals →

5  out of 5 stars
a diner from St. Petersburg, Florida
This information is a year and a half old but we are going back to New York in a few days and if we go to the Gotham Bar and Grill again, I will update it the review.
Let me say first off that we consider ourselves picky and like very good food and unpretentious surroundings. We considered this restaurant to be classy but unpretentious.
We had the "prefix" lunch which was $20.00 at the time. I believe they price it according to what the year is.
My husband had the Salmon and I had a pasta dish. I did not like my dish but it wasn't because it wasn't good, it was personal taste. I switched with my husband and I loved his Salmon and he liked my pasta very much! The lunch was three courses and very ample portions. It started with a very nice Endive salad and ended with a fabulous chocolate cake.
You had a choice of several entrees and also salads and desserts I believe.
The only extra cost was for your drinks and tip of course. The service was great and the restaurant was very very clean!
The only surprize was my southern sister ordered iced tea and she had two refills as the glasses were small, and it cost the same as my glass of champagne (9.00). I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone. If you frequent "all you can eat" and "mom's home cooking" and Cracker Barrel type restaurants, don't go here!

50% Off Dining Certificates at these locations...
New American
French, New American, Bar
Chinese, New American

Reviews of Similar Restaurants

American, Casual/Family, Bar, Kids Friendly
Walking into Moran's during the week it would seem like your average restaurant/pub, but looks can be deceiving. My husband and I visited several catering halls and researched a few restaurants for our wedding, but nothing seemed like the right fit u ...
American, Casual/Family, Bar, Kids Friendly
Finally a fun place in the neighborhood. Loud music and fun bartenders unlike the usual midtown irish bars. Even saw a girl dancing on the bar last week.
American, Casual/Family, Bar, Kids Friendly
My girlfriends and I meet there every thurs to share a few scorpion bowls. Don't drink too many they are super strong.
American, Casual/Family, Bar, Kids Friendly
Nice place great hamburgers and happy hour.
American, Casual/Family, Bar, Kids Friendly
Burgers are out of this world. Bleu cheese and bacon my favorite. Pretty big and not the usual midtown ripoff.

Read More: New York Restaurant Reviews

Avg Rating: 4  out of 5 stars

Number of Reviews: 1

5  out of 5 stars
a diner from St. Petersburg, Florida
This information is a year and a half old but we are going back to New York in a few days and if we go to the Gotham Bar and Grill again, I will update it the review.
Let me say first off that we consider ourselves picky and like very good food and unpretentious surroundings. We considered this restaurant to be classy but unpretentious.
We had the "prefix" lunch which was $20.00 at the time. I believe they price it according to what the year is.
My husband had the Salmon and I had a pasta dish. I did not like my dish but it wasn't because it wasn't good, it was personal taste. I switched with my husband and I loved his Salmon and he liked my pasta very much! The lunch was three courses and very ample portions. It started with a very nice Endive salad and ended with a fabulous chocolate cake.
You had a choice of several entrees and also salads and desserts I believe.
The only extra cost was for your drinks and tip of course. The service was great and the restaurant was very very clean!
The only surprize was my southern sister ordered iced tea and she had two refills as the glasses were small, and it cost the same as my glass of champagne (9.00). I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone. If you frequent "all you can eat" and "mom's home cooking" and Cracker Barrel type restaurants, don't go here!
Read More New York Restaurant Reviews

Gotham Bar And Grill Map

Recent Gotham Bar And Grill Reviews

5  out of 5 stars
a diner from St. Petersburg, Florida
This information is a year and a half old but we are going back to New York in a few days and if we go to the Gotham Bar and Grill again, I will update it the review.
Let me say first off that we consider ourselves picky and like very good food and unpretentious surroundings. We considered this restaurant to be classy but unpretentious.
We had the "prefix" lunch which was $20.00 at the time. I believe they price it according to what the year is.
My husband had the Salmon and I had a pasta dish. I did not like my dish but it wasn't because it wasn't good, it was personal taste. I switched with my husband and I loved his Salmon and he liked my pasta very much! The lunch was three courses and very ample portions. It started with a very nice Endive salad and ended with a fabulous chocolate cake.
You had a choice of several entrees and also salads and desserts I believe.
The only extra cost was for your drinks and tip of course. The service was great and the restaurant was very very clean!
The only surprize was my southern sister ordered iced tea and she had two refills as the glasses were small, and it cost the same as my glass of champagne (9.00). I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone. If you frequent "all you can eat" and "mom's home cooking" and Cracker Barrel type restaurants, don't go here!

Dining Specials

Dinner on Ludlow
American, New American, Tapas, Bar
Out East
New American, Seafood

More in New York

Explore all restaurants in New York, NY