Staten Island Restaurant Guide

Bay Street Luncheonette

(718) 720-0922

1189 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10305

View Map

Looking for deals near here?

See Restaurant.com gift certificates for restaurants in 10305.

Browse Local Deals →


50% Off Dining Certificates at these locations...

Reviews of Similar Restaurants

American Traditional, New American
Although the name says "Diner," it is far from a diner. The food and ambiance are more like a wonderful restaurant. The food is exceptionally good. I would usually never order Italian food in anything other than an Italian Restaurant, however, Wood ...
American Traditional, New American
Horrible place for a party. It is dirty, smelly and uninviting. The food was greasy and oily and tasteless. The bacon was burned, the french toast looked like texas toast that they had dipped in eggs. I was insulted that someone would have the aud ...
American Traditional, New American
We have been going to the dinner for several years and the food has been getting from excellent to below average, (must had a change of chefs) also the place is no longer kept in good shape, is a shame it went from a great place to a well..not so goo ...
American Traditional, New American
Disappointing. Quality of food below Average. Value below average. Overpriced yet friendly customer service.
American Traditional, New American
my favorite place in staten island. kinda pricey but never lets you down. great for special occasions.

Read More: Staten Island Restaurant Reviews

Sorry, there are currently no reviews.

Read More Staten Island Restaurant Reviews

Bay Street Luncheonette Map

Dining Specials

Cafe Tallulah
American Traditional, French, Cafe Restaurant in
New York
Ducks Eatery
American Traditional, Cajun/Creole, French Restaurant in
New York

More in Staten Island

Explore all restaurants in Staten Island, NY