Old Forge Restaurant Guide & Dining Reviews
Featured Review
While in the Scranton/Wilkes Barre area on a Saturday afternoon, my family and I wanted to try the much publicized Old Forge pizza. There are many choices along Main St. and we chose Arcaro & Genell's.
We arrived at the tavern around 4PM. There is both on & off street parking. We were promptly seated and provided with a bean salad and bread appetizer. The red square cut pizza was very good, as was the antipasto salad. The cannolis were extremely good, fresh & large. The food portion size was also good.
Our waitress was very attentive and provided fast and courteous service.
The dining area was very clean. The restroom was somewhat clean but could have been cleaner.
We will definitely return to Acaro & Genell's when... 
Recent Reviews
Anthonys Restaurant
“Best food in the area!!”
Cafe Rinaldi
“Cafe Rinaldi is an amazing restaurant. The mood is awesome, the atmosphere is wonderful and it's just a fabulous dining experience overall (even when they are super busy). I am a long time patron of Rinaldi's, back... ”
Amadeo's
“Amadeo's is my favorite restaurant, I have been a long time patron of the owner, he is a wonderful chef. The food is unbelievable. The prices are very reasonable and the portions are huge. Friendly and efficient s... ”
Brutico's Restaurant
“My husband and I go out to dinner every Friday. This past Friday we went to Bruticos with another couple. It was our first time, but definitely not our last.
We've all been talking about it ever since.
The atmos... ”
Amadeo's
“Absolutely fabulous restaurant. They haven't gone wrong yet with any dishes I've ordered. My favorite is the Chicken Caesar Salad. I love leafy salads - not those kind that just throw the left over lettuce pieces in... ”
Anthonys Restaurant 
“My boyfriend and I ate there several weeks ago for the first time. We arrived early (at about 5 pm) and were seated at the first table near the bar as you walk through the front door. (We were the only customers sea... ”
Amadeo's
“Great restaurant. Their food is exceptional and their risotto with white sauce is the best in Old Forge.”
Brutico's Restaurant 
“You get better service at McDonalds!!!! The salad was horrible and since when is merlot white? And I thought ordering something meduium had some pink in it??? Not shoe leather. Better off crossing the street to Gene... ”
Cafe Rinaldi
“The best Chicken Parm in PA. One of the best overall restaurants in the area.”
Anthonys Restaurant
“Anthony's is simply the best! Excellent From the minute you walk in to the minute you leave you feel at home. Everyone is friendly and kind. The food is beyond words. This is a five star (six start)restaurant! I... ”
Amadeo's
“This is by far one of my favorite restaurants around. The staff is a pleasure to be around. Just make sure you call to make reservations because its so good, it books up fast..”
Chickey's Diner
“This is by far the best small diner in Lackawanna County!!! The owner makes the pies and soup daily from scratch, food is always fresh and tasty, try the rice pudding also home made!!! We go there every week, it's s... ”
Amadeo's 
“The food was very good.”
Anthonys Restaurant
“Anthony's is a go to for us. The food is always perfect and worth the $$ spent. We have not found a better place in the Scranton/Wilkes-Barre area..A few very close or equal competitors, but none appreciably better.”
