h
Popular Cities
Indianapolis Restaurant Guide
Cuisine
St Elmo Steak House
(4 ratings)
(317) 635-0636
127 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Looking for deals near here?
See Restaurant.com gift certificates for restaurants in 46225.
Browse Local Deals →
May 4, 2007 @ 12:10 PM
a diner from Toledo, OH
Once again, St. Elmos my entree at St. Elmos underdelivered. This was my third trip to St. Elmos and each time my steak has been mediocre at best. Rather disappointing for a supposedly high ranking steakhouse. Everything else about the experience was above average. We were fortunate to get a table downstairs which was less crowded than the elbow to elbow dining on the main floor. Our service was good and the wind, shrimp cocktail and sides were all very good. Next time in Indy, I think I'll head to Moe's or Ruths Chris.
June 5, 2004 @ 6:26 PM
a diner from Tampa, Florida
Excellent service and food quality. The shrimp cocktail is legendary and worth the trip alone. Excellent location in downtown especially for dinner before or after a Pacer or Colts game.
Read More
St Elmo Steak House Reviews
Reviews of Similar Restaurants
Brewery/Pub/Tavern, Seafood, Sports Bar and Grill, Steak House
My dad is Skyler Neal,the DJ for Shiggs Diggs and he is great as asinger,dad,dj and person.And also if you name a song from 1970 to present he'll probably have it.not just him but the whole staff is great.The business went out of business and the own
...
Brewery/Pub/Tavern, Seafood, Sports Bar and Grill, Steak House
It seems like every other time i go they get my order wrong. I like the food but its getting annoying to drive home and then finding out that my meal is wrong and then having to drive back to get the right meal.
Brewery/Pub/Tavern, Seafood, Sports Bar and Grill, Steak House
Good food and big portions
This is a tasty, casual restaurant that's always nice to go to. The dining room is well decorated with paintings on the walls and a tree in the corner at Christmas time. The steaks are a little expensive, but all of the
...
Brewery/Pub/Tavern, Seafood, Sports Bar and Grill, Steak House
I was very pleased with this restaurant. Prices were good and the food was good. The service wasn't too bad considering our server had only been there almost a week. I got a Neon Margarita and I have to say that it was one of the best drinks I have h
...
Brewery/Pub/Tavern, Seafood, Sports Bar and Grill, Steak House
This place (and it's sister location on Pendleton Pike) is our favorite place to go, and not just for the Mexican food. The Cuevas Family are great people, and the quality and value of the food has never disappointed. The largest Chile Relleno I ha
...
Read More: Indianapolis Restaurant Reviews
Avg Rating:
Number of Reviews: 4
May 4, 2007 @ 12:10 PM
a diner from Toledo, OH
Once again, St. Elmos my entree at St. Elmos underdelivered. This was my third trip to St. Elmos and each time my steak has been mediocre at best. Rather disappointing for a supposedly high ranking steakhouse. Everything else about the experience was above average. We were fortunate to get a table downstairs which was less crowded than the elbow to elbow dining on the main floor. Our service was good and the wind, shrimp cocktail and sides were all very good. Next time in Indy, I think I'll head to Moe's or Ruths Chris.
June 5, 2004 @ 6:26 PM
a diner from Tampa, Florida
Excellent service and food quality. The shrimp cocktail is legendary and worth the trip alone. Excellent location in downtown especially for dinner before or after a Pacer or Colts game.
a diner from Bloomington, IN
St. Elmo's is the classic, original first steak
house of Indy. For steak lovers who appreciate
a relaxed atmosphere with top notch service and excellent food this is the place. Try the shrimp
cocktail with freshly made horseradish cocktail sauce which is a favorite.
house of Indy. For steak lovers who appreciate
a relaxed atmosphere with top notch service and excellent food this is the place. Try the shrimp
cocktail with freshly made horseradish cocktail sauce which is a favorite.
a diner from Indianapolis
This is THE place to eat if you really love steak. The flavor is perfection. The service can't be beat. You will not be disappointed here. The prices aren't for the weak of heart..but don't leave Indianapolis without trying it just once.
St Elmo Steak House Map
Recent St Elmo Steak House Reviews
May 4, 2007 @ 12:10 PM
a diner from Toledo, OH
Once again, St. Elmos my entree at St. Elmos underdelivered. This was my third trip to St. Elmos and each time my steak has been mediocre at best. Rather disappointing for a supposedly high ranking steakhouse. Everything else about the experience was above average. We were fortunate to get a table downstairs which was less crowded than the elbow to elbow dining on the main floor. Our service was good and the wind, shrimp cocktail and sides were all very good. Next time in Indy, I think I'll head to Moe's or Ruths Chris.
June 5, 2004 @ 6:26 PM
a diner from Tampa, Florida
Excellent service and food quality. The shrimp cocktail is legendary and worth the trip alone. Excellent location in downtown especially for dinner before or after a Pacer or Colts game.
More in Indianapolis
Explore all restaurants in Indianapolis, IN
- 12 reviews
- 9 reviews
- 8 reviews
- 7 reviews
- 7 reviews
- 7 reviews
- 6 reviews
- 6 reviews
