New York Restaurant Guide

Rosie O'grady's
3.7 stars (2 ratings)

(212) 582-2975

800 7th Ave, New York, NY 10019

View Map

Dining Specials

The Beekman Pub
American, Irish, Brewery/Pub/Tavern, Banquet/Party Room
American Cut
Steak House

October 8, 2006 @ 10:47 PM
1  out of 5 stars
a diner from Long Island, NY
I will never go back to Rosie o'Gradys. With the exception of the waiter who was very attentive and polite, the food was overpriced, poor quality in preparation and presentation. Whatever they are doing in the kitchen, is all wrong. Want a successful restaurant? Do the exact opposite of what they do in their kitchen.
We tried ordering 2 side dishes with our steaks which were undercooked by a lot, and they didn't have any more. How does a restaurant run out of Asparagus AND spinach in New York City? Aren't there produce grocers on practically every block in Manhattan? The bread was hard and stale, the food was just barely above room temperature, and the quality was that of a chain restaurant, for 32.95 per steak. Awful.
December 6, 2005 @ 9:51 AM
1  out of 5 stars
a diner from Brigantine, NJ
The staff treated my party rudely. When I mentioned it to the manager she said, "I told the girls to stop harrassing customers." The food was good but the waiter never came back to see how the food was or if anyone wanted another beverage. What really caught me off guard is when it was time to finally be seated at a table to eat the hostess shoved my niece and told her to move quickly.

50% Off Dining Certificates at these locations...
Greek, Seafood, Steak House
American, Irish, New American, Brewery/Pub/Tavern

Reviews of Similar Restaurants

Steak House, Kosher
I come here every Friday with my family for shabbat. its a great time for us to regroup pray eat and rejoice with one another. its beautifully setup with the candles and the roses. they also have 3 different menus to choose from , either one you pick ...
Steak House, Kosher
I bought a coupon online a couple months ago for Talia's Steakhouse and just used it tonight. I had never been there so I wasn't sure what to expect. It was amazing and I will definitely be back. The prix fixe deal was a great value, but aside fro ...
Steak House, Kosher
Evey time I come here I have an amazing experience! The food is awesome the service is the best I just love coming here!
Steak House, Kosher
It was a nice place however the prices are off the chart to expensive for a restaurant in Harlem. I payed 284 dollars for a 3ppl dinner. What did we order? lol
Steak House, Kosher
This past Saturday night, my boyfriend and I ate out with another couple at Talia’s steakhouse. Talia’s is actually open until 4am that night, and unexpectedly we stayed until closing. There was live music, and a bar, so we really felt like we were a ...

Read More: New York Restaurant Reviews

Avg Rating: 4  out of 5 stars

Number of Reviews: 2

October 8, 2006 @ 10:47 PM
1  out of 5 stars
a diner from Long Island, NY
I will never go back to Rosie o'Gradys. With the exception of the waiter who was very attentive and polite, the food was overpriced, poor quality in preparation and presentation. Whatever they are doing in the kitchen, is all wrong. Want a successful restaurant? Do the exact opposite of what they do in their kitchen.
We tried ordering 2 side dishes with our steaks which were undercooked by a lot, and they didn't have any more. How does a restaurant run out of Asparagus AND spinach in New York City? Aren't there produce grocers on practically every block in Manhattan? The bread was hard and stale, the food was just barely above room temperature, and the quality was that of a chain restaurant, for 32.95 per steak. Awful.
December 6, 2005 @ 9:51 AM
1  out of 5 stars
a diner from Brigantine, NJ
The staff treated my party rudely. When I mentioned it to the manager she said, "I told the girls to stop harrassing customers." The food was good but the waiter never came back to see how the food was or if anyone wanted another beverage. What really caught me off guard is when it was time to finally be seated at a table to eat the hostess shoved my niece and told her to move quickly.
Read More New York Restaurant Reviews

Rosie O'grady's Map

Recent Rosie O'grady's Reviews

October 8, 2006 @ 10:47 PM
1  out of 5 stars
a diner from Long Island, NY
I will never go back to Rosie o'Gradys. With the exception of the waiter who was very attentive and polite, the food was overpriced, poor quality in preparation and presentation. Whatever they are doing in the kitchen, is all wrong. Want a successful restaurant? Do the exact opposite of what they do in their kitchen.
We tried ordering 2 side dishes with our steaks which were undercooked by a lot, and they didn't have any more. How does a restaurant run out of Asparagus AND spinach in New York City? Aren't there produce grocers on practically every block in Manhattan? The bread was hard and stale, the food was just barely above room temperature, and the quality was that of a chain restaurant, for 32.95 per steak. Awful.
December 6, 2005 @ 9:51 AM
1  out of 5 stars
a diner from Brigantine, NJ
The staff treated my party rudely. When I mentioned it to the manager she said, "I told the girls to stop harrassing customers." The food was good but the waiter never came back to see how the food was or if anyone wanted another beverage. What really caught me off guard is when it was time to finally be seated at a table to eat the hostess shoved my niece and told her to move quickly.