Indianapolis Restaurant Guide
Indianapolis American Restaurant Reviews
Welcome to our Indianapolis American restaurant reviews guide where you'll find top restaurants off the beaten path, both locally owned and chain. In fact, some of the best restaurants in the Indianapolis just might be the little mom and pop operations flying under the radar. For some of the best picks in Indianapolis, you've come to the right place.
Our Indianapolis restaurant reviews guide can help you make sense of the thousands of options out there. Happy eating!
Also check out our Best Restaurants in Indianapolis 2025 Guide
Displaying 41 - 56 of 56
Sort By:
Latest Reviews
| Rating | A-Z
I saw the Groupon for their 8-course dinner with wine pairings and thought that $35 (originally $75) for a great deal for this package, so I purchased 5 certificates to take my family. The "8-course dinner" was very misleading because the helpings were sampler/small plates in size. Even more misle...
Overpriced lame cocktails, fair at best service. Food was pretty good, but I won't be back. Place was nearly empty on a Friday night at peak dining time....here's your sign!
The most recent and probably last time I went there my girlfriend & i had a very unprofessional experience. They recently consolidated their menu & took the buffalo chicken pizza away. We asked the kitchen manager if we could still order it & he said of course, just ask for it. So we go there with a...
i love eating in there and liseaing to the jutebox.
I had a very bad experience with a waiter that nearly overshadowed an otherwise wonderful evening. The staff at the Propylaeum Club is very small, so a problem with a staff member can be a very big deal. Our waiter was menacing from the start. He smiled with his mouth, but his eyes betrayed his extr...
the propyleaum is a great place for events.the staff was rudeand the food was horriable!
Even for a major markdown on Groupon this was a complete throwaway of an evening. The incessant bragging of the manager coupled with a 70's style microphone that was a parade of static was the backdrop. The food tasted like it was picked off of a two day old buffet and the waiters seemed confused ab...
Food was cold, chicken strips tasted fishy. When complained waitress informed me that I had to pay for the meal after eat one chicken strip. Not a good experience. Everyone in my group was not happy. One person in my party order Jack Daniels on the Rocks. Receipt read Jack Daniel $6 and $2 rocks...
my wife and i stopped there for breakfast,We were only people in store.Ordered biscuts and gravy(easy order) took very long time to recieve.While waiting for our order 5 customers came and went..Help in prep area had lot to be desired.Slow, very slow and joking with each other.Not a place you would...
My pork tenderloin was burnt, and the bar tender was really rude. She was on her phone the whole time I was there, as well as the owner. I felt I could have gotten better service if they paid more attention to my needs and not their phones. I am curious how much longer this place will be open.
Party of 5 ordered 2 Philly's, Club sandwich, Potato soup and a Quasdilla. Took an hour to get cold food. Beer was warm. Waitress was unconcerned about our complaints. They have a good menu and good food if you are lucky enough to receive it hot. This was our second time to try a quick meal befor...
I purchased an online coupon and was looking foward to my dining experience according to info and reviews put forth by the restaurant. What a bad joke! I ordered a grilled chicken strawberry salad... Expecting a meal size salad for $9.75 I was very disappointed when I received a "dinner size" salad....
(05/01/2011)
Tremendous historic building with lots of nooks and crannies to explore. The grand experience ends when you decide to partake of the boring limited menu. The person in charge assured us of a regal meal but quickly becamae a royal pain. They are not what they pretend to be here at this club.
(11/11/2012)
The server we had was awful. Took no ownership for the food being cold. The fried food was hot but my smoked chicken wings came out cold or lukewarm both times I sent them back. I told her to keep them the last time. Ordered a drink & I had to remind the waitress to get them after coming back to the...
(02/15/2011)
Big mikes is horrible. They never get my food right and always charge me way to much and when getting it delivered they take at least an hour. Worst place to eat ever
(10/24/2012)
Good food & ambiance but terrible manager on duty. Actually brought another customer over to verify the fries are always that well done. Embarrassing & not customer friendly. Even our waitress was embarrassed! No attempt made to satisfy the customer. Don't go at lunchtime.