Indianapolis Restaurant Guide
Indianapolis American Restaurant Reviews
Welcome to our Indianapolis American restaurant reviews guide where you'll find top restaurants off the beaten path, both locally owned and chain. In fact, some of the best restaurants in the Indianapolis just might be the little mom and pop operations flying under the radar. For some of the best picks in Indianapolis, you've come to the right place.
Our Indianapolis restaurant reviews guide can help you make sense of the thousands of options out there. Happy eating!
Also check out our Best Restaurants in Indianapolis 2025 Guide
Just left Big Mikes and it was fabulous. The food was delicious, staff was very nice and it has a very laid back and relaxing environment.This place is very affordable too! I would recommend if you havent tried it out yet.........Do it!!!
Waited an hour for our food. Server knew nothing about the food. The food was very spicy even the "mild sauce" was very hot. Steak did not taste good. Took forever to get a drink. "There was a hiccup in the kitchen". We complained and they did give us 4 meals for free.
The best fish sandwich I've had in Indy.
Though I have not physically been to Big Mikes, the food that was catered into our office was wonderful. I plan on checking out their lunch menu and going there myself. The delivery person was probably the nicest I have ever seen. Totally recommend for great service and awesome food!
I purchased an online coupon and was looking foward to my dining experience according to info and reviews put forth by the restaurant. What a bad joke! I ordered a grilled chicken strawberry salad... Expecting a meal size salad for $9.75 I was very disappointed when I received a "dinner size" salad....
Definitely NOT Russian the websites usually depict. Housed in location of former Russian Tea House which moved somewhere........... Enjoyable food. Got curdled cream for coffee but quickly rectified. Limited selection overall, but what we got was good. Several items had run out and were not told ...
Have you visited the Edelweiss Restaurant recently? The food is out of this world. And the prices are reasonable. Chef Ron Roberts does a fantastic job with his authentic German menu. Pork Schnitzel, Wiener Schnitzel, Sauerbraten, or whatever you have a hunger for, you will find done to your liking....
My favorite downtown comfort food restaurant. It's a hidden treasure. Very friendly staff, big portions and stress free, no frills place to eat.
Overpriced lame cocktails, fair at best service. Food was pretty good, but I won't be back. Place was nearly empty on a Friday night at peak dining time....here's your sign!
the propyleaum is a great place for events.the staff was rudeand the food was horriable!
Party of 5 ordered 2 Philly's, Club sandwich, Potato soup and a Quasdilla. Took an hour to get cold food. Beer was warm. Waitress was unconcerned about our complaints. They have a good menu and good food if you are lucky enough to receive it hot. This was our second time to try a quick meal befor...
Took the family to enjoy all of the Colts pictures, framed signed jerseys and other interesting stuff, and sat in a booth where the kids could watch a flat screened tv. There is one in each booth. I had a breaded tenderloin and my wife had a wrap, which she said was the best. They have 3 big, big...
A very impressive sports oriented home town bar and grill. If you are a Colts fan, you have to visit it. It's brimming with Colts stuff from floor to ceiling. Good pricing also.
Very impressed! Finally found a place close to home where the staff knows everyone by name and makes newcomers feel very comfortable. The food was great! Not your typically bar food, their tenderloins and fish & chips are amazing, can't wait to try other items off the menu. Definitely worth the trip...
When considering the superior quality (every time) and taste of the food, consistently outstanding service (family style), charming, one-of-a-kind atmosphere and reasonable price - there is NO DOUBT that Hollyhock Hill is the best overall restaurant in Indianapolis!
My pork tenderloin was burnt, and the bar tender was really rude. She was on her phone the whole time I was there, as well as the owner. I felt I could have gotten better service if they paid more attention to my needs and not their phones. I am curious how much longer this place will be open.
Great atmosphere, very clean and the food is always great. It is nice to have a local independent restaurant on the Southeast side of town.
I had a very bad experience with a waiter that nearly overshadowed an otherwise wonderful evening. The staff at the Propylaeum Club is very small, so a problem with a staff member can be a very big deal. Our waiter was menacing from the start. He smiled with his mouth, but his eyes betrayed his extr...
I have been to all the pubs in this area for lunch, dinner, and just kicking back. By far this is the best place to come when your near Indy. At lunch the service is the quickest anywhere. The drink prices are by far better than anyone in the area. Dinner is a great bargin too. Hands down best tende...
management is excellent