Indianapolis Restaurant Guide
Indianapolis American Restaurant Reviews
Welcome to our Indianapolis American restaurant reviews guide where you'll find top restaurants off the beaten path, both locally owned and chain. In fact, some of the best restaurants in the Indianapolis just might be the little mom and pop operations flying under the radar. For some of the best picks in Indianapolis, you've come to the right place.
Our Indianapolis restaurant reviews guide can help you make sense of the thousands of options out there. Happy eating!
Also check out our Best Restaurants in Indianapolis 2025 Guide
Displaying 21 - 40 of 56
Sort By:
Latest Reviews
| Rating | A-Z
i love eating in there and liseaing to the jutebox.
Down home cooking. Very reasonable. Smoking allowed. Down home attmosphere. Very fast service. Ideal for lunch time.
My favorite downtown comfort food restaurant. It's a hidden treasure. Very friendly staff, big portions and stress free, no frills place to eat.
The most recent and probably last time I went there my girlfriend & i had a very unprofessional experience. They recently consolidated their menu & took the buffalo chicken pizza away. We asked the kitchen manager if we could still order it & he said of course, just ask for it. So we go there with a...
What a great experience we had. I took my family here to eat and enjoyed my time there. We ordered pizza(always delicious) and my daughter was able to have fun in the play room. She had so much fun she didnt want to leave. I would so suggest this place to my friends and family. I love Gallagher's...
Food is fantastic you get a good feel for the Greek islands!
When considering the superior quality (every time) and taste of the food, consistently outstanding service (family style), charming, one-of-a-kind atmosphere and reasonable price - there is NO DOUBT that Hollyhock Hill is the best overall restaurant in Indianapolis!
Outstanding restaurant with excellent food, fun atmosphere and lots of ambience.
They are known for the breaded tenderloin (it is as big as a platter size plate). The grilled tenderloin, chili cheese nachos and the french fries are also very good.
I have been to all the pubs in this area for lunch, dinner, and just kicking back. By far this is the best place to come when your near Indy. At lunch the service is the quickest anywhere. The drink prices are by far better than anyone in the area. Dinner is a great bargin too. Hands down best tende...
Midtown Grill is great for a date night or any kind of get-together. They have a nice dinning area, great food, and the best filet dijon in Broad Ripple. The atmosphere is romantic and elegant yet casual. Summer is my favorite time to go because they have nice outdoor seating. Then later in the ni...
Midtown Grill is great for a date night or any kind of get-together. They have a nice dinning area, great food, and the best filet dijon in Broad Ripple. The atmosphere is romantic and elegant yet casual. Summer is my favorite time to go because they have nice outdoor seating. Then later in the ni...
The food is delicious but the wait is ridiculous. We called ahead for seating and still had to wait 2 1/2 hours. We had small children with us which made the waiting difficult. The hostess was rude but the manager was accomodating. We received free appetizers bec of our long wait AFTER we intial...
Outback Steakhouse is never a disappointment. You can count on good-to-excellent food at a reasonable price. The waiters/waitresses really know their stuff. All in all a "better than average" place to dine.
Definitely NOT Russian the websites usually depict. Housed in location of former Russian Tea House which moved somewhere........... Enjoyable food. Got curdled cream for coffee but quickly rectified. Limited selection overall, but what we got was good. Several items had run out and were not told ...
(11/11/2012)
The server we had was awful. Took no ownership for the food being cold. The fried food was hot but my smoked chicken wings came out cold or lukewarm both times I sent them back. I told her to keep them the last time. Ordered a drink & I had to remind the waitress to get them after coming back to the...
Food was cold, chicken strips tasted fishy. When complained waitress informed me that I had to pay for the meal after eat one chicken strip. Not a good experience. Everyone in my group was not happy. One person in my party order Jack Daniels on the Rocks. Receipt read Jack Daniel $6 and $2 rocks...
Been there only once. Awesome experience! I built my own omelete and had a side of home fries. Very delicious and very filling. Went because I had a Groupon, glad I found it because I will be going back.
Waited an hour for our food. Server knew nothing about the food. The food was very spicy even the "mild sauce" was very hot. Steak did not taste good. Took forever to get a drink. "There was a hiccup in the kitchen". We complained and they did give us 4 meals for free.
All around great experience.The food and service was great! We went for the first time with our son and grandaughters- Since it was Sunday, the girls meals were free! What a nice perk! Loved the environment, the decor and the televisions!