PJ Charlton
American Traditional · New York, NY
American Traditional
Italian
Deals & ways to save
We don’t have a dining certificate or coupon for PJ Charlton in our current feed.
We may email you about local restaurant deals for the city you choose. See our Privacy Policy.
Diner reviews of PJ Charlton
A diner from New York, NY
Sep 14, 2010
I'm not the type of person to write a review on any restaurant, but sometimes you have one of those experiences that you can't let go unknown.
I have nothing but amazing things to say about the food, atmosphere, and service at this restaurant. I've spent many lunch hours here for great food and drinks to escape the crazy work day. Unfortunately for the restaurant, this place is usually dead, and on some occasions, I was the sole customer. But I liked this since I could really relax without loud and obnoxious patrons. I made friends with all of the staff, and would choose this restaurant over all others knowing I'd have great food and great company.
When two of the servers decided to move on from the restaurant to other jobs, I was extremely sad to see them leave since I looked forward to chatting with them every day.
Yesterday I went in for my usual salad and drink, and as I signed my credit card statement, the owner sat down and told me I'm not allowed back in the restaurant. Apparently, he thinks I "corrupted" his servers by accepting occasional drink buybacks. I've never been so confused and hurt by someone I barely know. When I asked "why?" I didn't receive more than the answer "because you corrupted them". I don't understand how anyone could blame their customers for accepting a drink "on us" when they are consistent customers who have done nothing but support the establishment. I've never been so disappointed and disrespected in my life. Any "buybacks" I received I paid for above and beyond in tips (which I'm sure he reaped the benefits of). On top of all of this, he had the nerve to "threaten" my job. In my state of confusion, I mentioned that I will be talking with my coworkers about this and that it may influence whether or not they choose to eat there. He retaliated with "if you still have your job....I know people over there".
Bottom line, the food here is incredible and the bartenders (if they still work there) are great, but the management is apparently not what it seems. Watch out getting too friendly with the staff, the management might get jealous.
A diner from New York, NY
May 5, 2010
This restaurant is tucked away on one of the last most desolate corners in SO HO. However once you arrive it is an oasis of great food at reasonable prices in a very comfortable setting;always plenty of fresh floral arrangements.It has thrived there for thirty years under the same ownership. They have recently started opening on Saturdays with plenty of free parking.It is minutes away from the overcrowded tiny table and over priced restaurants that dot the main streets in so ho. Truly a hidden marvel in so ho.
Write a review
Reviews of similar restaurants
The newest review from each of 6 other restaurants in New York.
-
Pizza Plus A Whole Lot More!
American Traditional, Italian, Pizzeria
A diner from NYC
Aug 9, 2012
I have lived in the neighborhood for years and I'm always pleased with their service. Extremely friendly staff and the food is always consistently good. Pizza is not bad. The buffalo wings are my favorite.
-
TGI Friday's
American Traditional
A diner from nyc
Aug 4, 2012
I have been with my family at TGIF in NYC on 677 Lexington Av on July 20th 2012. We were tourists in the city. We got very poor service. WE WILL Never visit TGIF AGAIN!!! First the waitress that took our drink order came
-
Mercato
Italian
No star rating
A diner from New York City
Jun 5, 2012
Great ambience, good food, lots of fun in a neighborhood where it's hard to find a great restaurant
-
Barbarini Mercato
Italian
A diner from Montvale, NJ
Mar 25, 2012
Terrible. Service was not quick My salmon dish wash not fresh nor cooked all the way.
-
Prohibition
American, American Traditional, Live Entertainment, Off Beat
A diner from new york, NY
Nov 27, 2011
I was touched inappropriately by the busboy. When I complained, the "manager" cursed at me and spoke to me equally inappropriately. There are so many choices on the Upper West Side, avoid this one!!!
-
Casa Bella Restaurant
Italian
No star rating
A diner from Philadelphia, PA
Nov 18, 2011
very disappointed...the man outside was very likable and talked us into dining there even though we were heading some where else. once in, other than the waiter's HELPER (the helper did a great job with the drinks and b