Name: New City Diner
Address: 127 Route 304, Nanuet, NY, 10954, US
Telephone: +1-845-624-1400
Rating: 1.5

ActiveDiner diner Jun 9, 2014

Four of us had dinner on June 5. One of each couple had salad with the meal. Each of us suffered diarrhea the next day.

A diner from New City, NY Jul 8, 2013

Went there last night and it was absolutely revolting. Buffalo wings with no seasoning and the waiter tells me "In 15 years he has never heard of buffalo wings being spicy. They are supposed to be plain." I'm guessing that I had to pay extra in order for them to be cooked all the way through. And the ONE potato skin looked like it had been replated from three days ago along with the single piece of eggplant. I know the sampler is primarily fried foods but I guess they tossed in the excess oil that was all over the plate at no charge. The manager was decent and took $5 off the bill. But the food is nauseating and far over priced for the crap that ends up being served on a plate to you. I've been going there for years but can promise I won't be returning.

A diner from New City Jun 11, 2011

My wife and spent about $45 for two dinners. My dinner came with dessert which was anything I desired.. Instead, I asked the waiter to just give me a cup of coffee instead of the dessert. He told me he could not substitute anything for the dessert. From a money aspect I knew that a cup of coffee was much cheaper than a slice of cake so I asked to speak with the manager. The manager came over and told me in a very unfriendly way that there would be no substitute. I thought, wouldn't it be good business to make the change especially when it would be less costly for the restaurant. I then explained that I have dinner there at least twice a month and that if this was his final decision I would not eat there anymore. He couldn't care less and just walked away. So having this experience I would recommend not eating in this restaurant. I have passed this on to all my friends who are no longer patronizing this establishment.

A diner from pomona, NY May 1, 2010

I had a Caesar salad with grilled chicken and one unsweetened iced tea. The bill was $16.90. With tip close to $20. The salad was good. Not twenty bucks good. Very overpriced.

A diner from yorktown ny Dec 9, 2009

the waitress sitting at the table sneezing into her hands should have told me to walk out. i did not. between the hundreds of dusty fake flowers and "ambiance", and the outrageously priced food-$32.00 for breakfast for two I will cross them off my list of eateries.

A diner from Yorktown, NY Nov 30, 2008

This diner is a rip-off. Their diner on 202 in Yorktown is even worse. The food is very expensive. They overcharge for every little extra or substitution. Not worth the experience.
Avoid.

A diner from poughkeepsie ny Oct 11, 2008

this is the worst diner that i ever ate in. they couldn't even melt cheese for a grilled cheese

No star rating A diner from Pearl River, NY Jul 29, 2008

It's been a number of years since I went to the New City Diner. I noticed the last several times I went the others who came later than I were seated while I waited. I asked hostess if it was policy to seat couples before singes and she said "Yes." I told her to take my name off the list and she immediately gave me a booth. I have never been back. I would prefer to eat where I am welcomed.

A diner from NYACK Apr 14, 2008

OVER PRICED! MORE THEN GOING OUT TO ONE OF ROCKLANDS
NICE RESTURANTS, SERVICE IS BAD, FOOD SO SO, TYPICAL DINER FOOD AT RESTURAUNT PRICES, NOT RECOMENDED!

Popular Cities

Cuisine

Nearby Cities

New City Diner

Location & contact

Deals & ways to save

Diner reviews of New City Diner

Reviews of similar restaurants

More in Nanuet

Quick Links

About Us