Nanuet Restaurant Guide

New City Diner
1.8 stars (6 ratings)

(845) 624-1400

127 Route 304, Nanuet, NY 10954

View Map

Dining Specials

Aj's Bar & Grill
American, Brewery/Pub/Tavern, Sports Bar and Grill, Steak House Restaurant in
Yorktown
5  out of 5 stars
5|This is our go to place! Stacy the bartender, is great!!! Food is delicous,atmosphere is great! j...
Buccaneer Diner
American, Diner, Steak House, Fast Food Restaurant in
East Elmhurst
5  out of 5 stars
5|I've been going to this diner probably since I was an infant. The people are great, the food is gr...

July 8, 2013 @ 1:47 PM
1  out of 5 stars
a diner from New City, NY
Went there last night and it was absolutely revolting. Buffalo wings with no seasoning and the waiter tells me "In 15 years he has never heard of buffalo wings being spicy. They are supposed to be plain." I'm guessing that I had to pay extra in order for them to be cooked all the way through. And the ONE potato skin looked like it had been replated from three days ago along with the single piece of eggplant. I know the sampler is primarily fried foods but I guess they tossed in the excess oil that was all over the plate at no charge. The manager was decent and took $5 off the bill. But the food is nauseating and far over priced for the crap that ends up being served on a plate to you. I've been going there for years but can promise I won't be returning.
May 1, 2010 @ 3:39 PM
3  out of 5 stars
a diner from pomona, ny
I had a Caesar salad with grilled chicken and one unsweetened iced tea. The bill was $16.90. With tip close to $20. The salad was good. Not twenty bucks good. Very overpriced.

50% Off Dining Certificates at these locations...
4  out of 5 stars
American, Brewery/Pub/Tavern Restaurant in
Flushing
American Restaurant in
Brooklyn
American Restaurant in
Brooklyn

Avg Rating: 2  out of 5 stars

Number of Reviews: 6

July 8, 2013 @ 1:47 PM
1  out of 5 stars
a diner from New City, NY
Went there last night and it was absolutely revolting. Buffalo wings with no seasoning and the waiter tells me "In 15 years he has never heard of buffalo wings being spicy. They are supposed to be plain." I'm guessing that I had to pay extra in order for them to be cooked all the way through. And the ONE potato skin looked like it had been replated from three days ago along with the single piece of eggplant. I know the sampler is primarily fried foods but I guess they tossed in the excess oil that was all over the plate at no charge. The manager was decent and took $5 off the bill. But the food is nauseating and far over priced for the crap that ends up being served on a plate to you. I've been going there for years but can promise I won't be returning.
May 1, 2010 @ 3:39 PM
3  out of 5 stars
a diner from pomona, ny
I had a Caesar salad with grilled chicken and one unsweetened iced tea. The bill was $16.90. With tip close to $20. The salad was good. Not twenty bucks good. Very overpriced.
November 30, 2008 @ 10:47 PM
1  out of 5 stars
a diner from Yorktown, NY
This diner is a rip-off. Their diner on 202 in Yorktown is even worse. The food is very expensive. They overcharge for every little extra or substitution. Not worth the experience.
Avoid.
October 11, 2008 @ 8:23 AM
2  out of 5 stars
a diner from poughkeepsie ny
this is the worst diner that i ever ate in. they couldn't even melt cheese for a grilled cheese
July 29, 2008 @ 6:58 PM
a diner from Pearl River, NY
It's been a number of years since I went to the New City Diner. I noticed the last several times I went the others who came later than I were seated while I waited. I asked hostess if it was policy to seat couples before singes and she said "Yes." I told her to take my name off the list and she immediately gave me a booth. I have never been back. I would prefer to eat where I am welcomed.
April 14, 2008 @ 12:22 PM
1  out of 5 stars
a diner from NYACK
OVER PRICED! MORE THEN GOING OUT TO ONE OF ROCKLANDS
NICE RESTURANTS, SERVICE IS BAD, FOOD SO SO, TYPICAL DINER FOOD AT RESTURAUNT PRICES, NOT RECOMENDED!
Read More Nanuet Restaurant Reviews

New City Diner Map

Recent New City Diner Reviews

July 8, 2013 @ 1:47 PM
1  out of 5 stars
a diner from New City, NY
Went there last night and it was absolutely revolting. Buffalo wings with no seasoning and the waiter tells me "In 15 years he has never heard of buffalo wings being spicy. They are supposed to be plain." I'm guessing that I had to pay extra in order for them to be cooked all the way through. And the ONE potato skin looked like it had been replated from three days ago along with the single piece of eggplant. I know the sampler is primarily fried foods but I guess they tossed in the excess oil that was all over the plate at no charge. The manager was decent and took $5 off the bill. But the food is nauseating and far over priced for the crap that ends up being served on a plate to you. I've been going there for years but can promise I won't be returning.
May 1, 2010 @ 3:39 PM
3  out of 5 stars
a diner from pomona, ny
I had a Caesar salad with grilled chicken and one unsweetened iced tea. The bill was $16.90. With tip close to $20. The salad was good. Not twenty bucks good. Very overpriced.