Nyack Restaurant Guide

Amici Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
4.4 stars (5 ratings)

(845) 353-1650

303 Route 59, Nyack, NY 10960

View Map

Dining Specials

Karma - NY
American Restaurant in
Nyack
Szechuan House
Chinese Restaurant in
Nyack

Italian Food & Culture History

March 23, 2011 @ 4:39 PM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from new city ny
if you are ever driving down 59 and happend to miss AMicis then your missing out on the best atmosphere in rockland county. The food there is impeccable to taste and the most amazing thing is the people that work behind the counter the owner and his daughter are amazing people who work hard to make the costumers happy ! and if you are on of those people like the first comment that cannot read the menu correctly ! all of the amazing food comes with salad and bread and pasta what more could you ask for this place is greatt love it from the pizza to the weekly specials !!!
October 24, 2009 @ 5:56 PM
2  out of 5 stars
a diner from Nyack, NY
Ordered from Amici, over $50 worth of food - we ordered separate salads because we were not informed when placing order that pasta we got already came with salad - so we ended up having 4 salads..... the small tray the pasta came in was half empty - 6 pieces of ravioli for $9.... not worh the money... Best part - the (how she called herself) "owner Tina", when calling back with some constructive criticism, called us liars, threatend us to come to our business (we are local business place) and - literally - "kick our butts".... Way to go tina, now you have a bad online review. Wouldn't hurt to be more polite at times....

50% Off Dining Certificates at these locations...
American Restaurant in
Nyack
5  out of 5 stars
European, Italian, Ethnic Setting, Banquet/Party Room Restaurant in
Harrison
5  out of 5 stars
Italian, Casual/Family, Kids Friendly, Outdoor Seating Restaurant in
Brooklyn

Reviews of Similar Restaurants

Pizzeria
Best pizza place in Rockland county. Pizza consistently superb... good variety... reasonable price. Too bad they eliminated the outdoor seating which, unfortunately, became a mecca for undesirable elements in the past. Hope they can bring it back ...
Pizzeria
Once you have tried the rest then try the best. Stop in at Tarantella Pizzeria and Restaurant for the best Italian food,heroes,appetizers and of course the tastiest pizza in Rockland County. If you choose pasta or meat dishes, regular traditional piz ...
Pizzeria
I REALLY LOVE THE PIZZA!!!
Pizzeria
the pizza is the best in nyack but i go there for the korean cannoli.
Pizzeria
THIS IS THE BEST PIZZA ON THE PLANET. Must get a slice...

Read More: Nyack Restaurant Reviews

Avg Rating: 4  out of 5 stars

Number of Reviews: 5

March 23, 2011 @ 4:39 PM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from new city ny
if you are ever driving down 59 and happend to miss AMicis then your missing out on the best atmosphere in rockland county. The food there is impeccable to taste and the most amazing thing is the people that work behind the counter the owner and his daughter are amazing people who work hard to make the costumers happy ! and if you are on of those people like the first comment that cannot read the menu correctly ! all of the amazing food comes with salad and bread and pasta what more could you ask for this place is greatt love it from the pizza to the weekly specials !!!
October 24, 2009 @ 5:56 PM
2  out of 5 stars
a diner from Nyack, NY
Ordered from Amici, over $50 worth of food - we ordered separate salads because we were not informed when placing order that pasta we got already came with salad - so we ended up having 4 salads..... the small tray the pasta came in was half empty - 6 pieces of ravioli for $9.... not worh the money... Best part - the (how she called herself) "owner Tina", when calling back with some constructive criticism, called us liars, threatend us to come to our business (we are local business place) and - literally - "kick our butts".... Way to go tina, now you have a bad online review. Wouldn't hurt to be more polite at times....
June 23, 2009 @ 10:22 AM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from Nyack
The best pizza that I have had. The taste is unlike any other. Fresh and full of flavor. I am a pizza lover and I try pizza all over the place. Amicis by far is my favorite. Not only is there pizza amazing, their pasta is just as delicious.
December 5, 2008 @ 2:43 PM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from nyack ny
I was looking for a place in Nyack that was kid friendly, had decent food, and in a pinch would deliver. Having enjoyed the pizza from time to time while shopping nearby I decided to give the back room dining area a try. What a revelation!The food was excellent. The Mussels Marinara is a must try as is the chicken florentine. Staples such as eggplant, chicken or veal parmigiana were delicious and very generously portioned. Specials such as veal stew over rigatoni or their exceptional sauteed brocolli raab were comparable or superior to some much fancier establishments. If I had one gripe it would be the decor, which needs updating, but that is nitpicking.The service is attentive if somewhat work-a-day and the proprietor always let's you know how special you are to him. I'd recommend this place to anyone looking for excellent fresh Italian food for a great price in a laid back atmosphere.
November 8, 2007 @ 11:03 AM
a diner from Nyack, ny
It's pretty hard to get a bad slice of pizza in Nyack, but if you're looking for a slice that will awaken your senses, this is the place. They have a tomato and garlic slice that will blow your mind and a chicken pesto slice is that is delicious. It's a small restaurant, but the people that work behind the counter have character and make you feel welcome. Their dough is perfect; it's thin, crispy on the bottom, and soft but cooked on top. The mix of spices they use on their pizza is tantalizing. When you walk in your nose thanks you. All I've tried was the pizza but am looking forward to expanding my horizons.
Read More Nyack Restaurant Reviews

Amici Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Map

Recent Amici Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Reviews

March 23, 2011 @ 4:39 PM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from new city ny
if you are ever driving down 59 and happend to miss AMicis then your missing out on the best atmosphere in rockland county. The food there is impeccable to taste and the most amazing thing is the people that work behind the counter the owner and his daughter are amazing people who work hard to make the costumers happy ! and if you are on of those people like the first comment that cannot read the menu correctly ! all of the amazing food comes with salad and bread and pasta what more could you ask for this place is greatt love it from the pizza to the weekly specials !!!
October 24, 2009 @ 5:56 PM
2  out of 5 stars
a diner from Nyack, NY
Ordered from Amici, over $50 worth of food - we ordered separate salads because we were not informed when placing order that pasta we got already came with salad - so we ended up having 4 salads..... the small tray the pasta came in was half empty - 6 pieces of ravioli for $9.... not worh the money... Best part - the (how she called herself) "owner Tina", when calling back with some constructive criticism, called us liars, threatend us to come to our business (we are local business place) and - literally - "kick our butts".... Way to go tina, now you have a bad online review. Wouldn't hurt to be more polite at times....