Youngstown Restaurant Guide

Reviews By Cuisine

Other City Reviews

Youngstown italian Restaurant Reviews

Youngstown italian restaurant reviews photo

Welcome to our Youngstown italian restaurant reviews guide where you'll find top restaurants off the beaten path, both locally owned and chain. In fact, some of the best restaurants in the Youngstown just might be the little mom and pop operations flying under the radar. For some of the best picks in Youngstown, you've come to the right place.

Our Youngstown restaurant reviews guide can help you make sense of the thousands of options out there. Happy eating!

Also check out our Best Restaurants in Youngstown 2025 Guide

Displaying 1 - 9 of 9
Sort By: Latest Reviews | Rating | A-Z
Antone's Italian Cafe - Austintown
1 star(s)
(11/19/2011)
I cannot say anything nice about this place. First, my food was cold, and the employees acted like they didn't care to help me. That wasn't the worst of it though. I found a free present in my salad.....a COCKROACH. Mmmmmmmmm yummy!! Protein anybody?
Antone's Italian Cafe - Austintown
(10/10/2010)
we had the worst experience it ruined my bday i wrote back in july cause i had allergic reaction they need to listen to people i had to leave and go to er be put through alot of pain and shots and pay alot for meds not cool my girl wrote u guys never heard from u guys so not cool we spent over 80.00...
Rusty's Southside Grill
3 star(s)
(06/21/2010)
Employee review: I have been a part of the Rusty' s work crew for over one year. We ( the staff) have many complaints about where the money we make goes. Servers tip out at the end of the night to the buss boy every night . Money has been discovered missing almost every day . Management is very rude...
Belleria Pizza & Pasta
5 star(s)
(03/24/2009)
Belleria Pizza on Youngstown Poland Road is wonderful. We have eaten there many times and have ordered take out very often UNTIL they stopped putting french fries on their steak salad. Their steak salad is wonderful, but with no french fries on it...well, we go to either Belleria in Campbell or Bri...
Scacchetti's Italian Steakhouse
1 star(s)
(03/23/2009)
The food was cold and so was the service !The drinks were hit -not made right - with out the proper garnish. {People enjoy an olive with a martini ...strange as that seems.}We will not be back because sub-par service should not be rewarded with a tip added on a partys check.Our service was ...
Scacchetti's Italian Steakhouse
5 star(s)
(03/02/2009)
Excellent food. The bar area is amazing, like Vegas or N.Y.C., and the bartenders are amazing!
City Limits Restaurant
5 star(s)
(02/03/2009)
Very good food, service very friendly make you feel at home, out to please the customer.
Scacchetti's Italian Steakhouse
5 star(s)
(03/28/2007)
The food is great, cudos to the owners for the smoke free atmosphere. Friendly folks.
Belleria Pizza & Pasta
5 star(s)
(10/22/2004)
The food is excellent from the pizzas to the salads and everything in between.

Quick Links

About Us

Stemming from a desire to find dining information on the internet, ActiveDiner's designers soon realized that there were others like them....Learn More

Get ActiveDiner on the iPhone

Subcribe for Deals

Get on our mailing list for the latest dining specials.

Copyright 1996-2026 ActiveDiner.com All rights reserved.

ActiveDiner may earn a commission when you buy through links on this site, at no extra cost to you.