follow us on twitter    Get ActiveDiner on the iPhone

Reviews By Cuisine

All Reviews (50)
American (4)
Brewery/Pub/Tavern (1)
Chicken (1)
Italian (7)
Japanese (2)
Pizzeria (4)
Seafood (3)
Sports Bar and Grill (1)
Steak House (6)

Other City Reviews

East Liverpool
East Palestine

Youngstown Restaurant Reviews

Youngstown  restaurant reviews photo

Welcome to our Youngstown restaurant reviews guide where you'll find top restaurants off the beaten path, both locally owned and chain. In fact, some of the best restaurants in the Youngstown just might be the little mom and pop operations flying under the radar. For some of the best picks in Youngstown, you've come to the right place.

Our Youngstown restaurant reviews guide can help you make sense of the thousands of options out there. Happy eating!

Also check out our Best Restaurants in Youngstown 2016 Guide

Sort By:  Latest Reviews | Rating | A-Z  
Displaying 1 - 20 of 50

All Starz Sports Grille

 4 star(s)  (02/24/2011)
“Food was hot and tasty-good portions. Love that u can always view a tv no matter where u sit! Staff is very pleasant.”

Anthony's On the River

 1 star(s)  (09/18/2006)
“I do not recommend this reatraunt to any one. I ordered the Pork Tenderloin, I've seen more and better tasting meat on an Arby's reg roast beef.”

Anthony's On the River

 4 star(s)  (11/05/2007)
“A local treasure! I have never been disappointed whether it's a luncheon or dinner experience.”

Anthony's On the River

 5 star(s)  (03/21/2004)
“amazing food in a beautiful setting. we had chef judy's pork tendersion with wild mushroom and red wine sauce and it was incredble! desserts are all homemade and extremely creative, the creme brulee and walnut fudge tart were the best i have ever eaten”

Anthony's On the River

 5 star(s)  (09/15/2007)
“Anthony's on the River in downtown Youngstown is the best dining experience I have had in the tri-county region. The food is consistently good. Whether your in the mood for chicken,pork, or beef they serve the best. I enjoyed the charred rib eye steak which melted in my mouth. Excellent food and ser... ”

Anthony's On the River

 5 star(s)  (04/01/2008)
“I've never had a bad meal at this restaurant. Everything is excellent. The service is great. The restaurant is very nicely decorated and very clean.”


 1 star(s)  (07/12/2009)
“We ate at your restaurant located in boardman, ohio. I was a very poor enviroment and food. The cleanliness was terrible. The booths and tables were not kept clean. In the booth that we sat in there were grease and food stains on the windows between the booths and trash on the floor. We were ser... ”

Asuka Japanese Cuisine

 5 star(s)  (12/28/2007)
“it was pretty sweeeet(: they are all really nice and the chicken is good :D”

Avalon Gardens

 1 star(s)  (06/09/2009)
“Im not sure what happenned to this restaurant it used to be one of the best places to go. This is the second time we have tried to eat there and had to leave because the service was just terrible. There were several other people that left as well and those that were left were complaining very loudly... ”

Avalon Gardens

 5 star(s)  (01/13/2010)
“Best pizza in town and possibly the best I have ever had. They make the pizza's fresh so it might take a while for your food to come out but its worth it.”

Belleria Pizza & Pasta

 5 star(s)  (10/22/2004)
“The food is excellent from the pizzas to the salads and everything in between.”

Belleria Pizza & Pasta

 5 star(s)  (03/24/2009)
“Belleria Pizza on Youngstown Poland Road is wonderful. We have eaten there many times and have ordered take out very often UNTIL they stopped putting french fries on their steak salad. Their steak salad is wonderful, but with no french fries on it...well, we go to either Belleria in Campbell or Bri... ”

Charly's Family Restaurant by Mr B

 4 star(s)  (11/20/2000)
“Not an "atmosphere" restaurant--just really good food at a reasonable price. We try to eat here whenever we get back in town.”

City Limits Restaurant

 5 star(s)  (02/03/2009)
“Very good food, service very friendly make you feel at home, out to please the customer.”

Dairy Queen - Poland

 1 star(s)  (05/11/2009)
“Without a doubt the worse service at any ice cream shop in the area. Service is "SO SLOW" you will want to pull your hair out if they have two people ahead of you. Especially if it is evening and teenage diva staff night. Thinking and smiling is beyond their capabilities. You will leave wondering wh... ”

Luciannos Restaurant

 1 star(s)  (04/08/2006)
“Their food has gone downhill and the service and portions suck.”

Luciannos Restaurant

 1 star(s)  (02/23/2007)
“The food is not that great and they still allow smoking despite the new law.”

Luciannos Restaurant

 1 star(s)  (11/28/2009)
“I have been to both the new and old restaurants, i cant stand majority of the people that work there and think they are on top of the world, and the pasta sauce is DISGUSTING. It seemed as if the new place just made the whole attitude seem far worse. I like to go somewhere and feel welcome, i always... ”

Luciannos Restaurant

 1 star(s)  (09/18/2013)
“Terrible service food was cold and to top it off food there was not good at all”

Luciannos Restaurant

 4 star(s)  (11/20/2000)
“Although quality seems to have slipped just a bit in the past two years this is still a good place to get great Italian food. ”

Read more Youngstown restaurant reviews >>