Dayton Restaurant Guide
Dayton Barbecue Restaurant Reviews
Welcome to our Dayton Barbecue restaurant reviews guide where you'll find top restaurants off the beaten path, both locally owned and chain. In fact, some of the best restaurants in the Dayton just might be the little mom and pop operations flying under the radar. For some of the best picks in Dayton, you've come to the right place.
Our Dayton restaurant reviews guide can help you make sense of the thousands of options out there. Happy eating!
Also check out our Best Restaurants in Dayton 2025 Guide
Displaying 21 - 33 of 33
Sort By:
Latest Reviews
| Rating | A-Z
I hate to read bad reviews of this place, as our family loves it! I order the Roquefort burger every time and it's seriously the best burger i have ever had! We went today and everything was so fresh and hot...that I could barely eat my fries. Not a complaint---very fresh! I also had the salad with ...
Some friends took me out for my birthday. They told me we were going to Old Hickory on Brown St.I said ok I never ate at that one, only ate at the one on Main. Well I really enjoyed myself and everything was just as they said exellent, even our waitor Billie, he was one of the nices young man I have...
This restaurant has the best broasted chicken and potatoes in the Dayton area. Their house dressing and homemade cole slaw are also the greatest! I highly reccommend it.
Best BBQ chicken in the Dayton and surrounding areas. Hometown look and feel. You take a step into the past when you enter the door. Great value! We make the make the trip often.
I would give Barbecue Hut a high five on all their food and their help. We eat there at least once a week. Jim the owner is a real nice person and makes you feel confortable while you are there. Their food is the best and their Barbecue is the best. I hope they never close.
Old Hickory has the best prime rib, steaks, and chicken. Their service was excellent and I will be going back again and agian.
Probably my first and last time at this resturant. Love ribs and of the 5 places I've had ribs the last year this was definetly the worst. Ribs were grisley, over cooked, with little meat on the bone! Baked potato was good! The starter salad was nothing more than iceberg lettece, (a bit of it was br...
Dry food with a dull atmosphere.
I ordered the very entree' that the restaurant should have perfect by now...the BBQ pork chop dinner. It took entirely too long to be served and when they arrived they were burnt, dry, and hard to cut. I showed the waitress who shouldn't have served them to begin with, and she took them back. It was...
We, as a party of 4 were greeted at our table 1 cold dinner roll, crackers and applesauce straight from the can (not even cinnamon). We ordered their "misleading" Texas BBQ sandwich, which was also BBQ from a can or container (like you get at the store). The atmoshphere was interesting with old anit...
This is a nice diner, but this is not a BBQ restaurant unfortunaly! Simply baking or heating meat then putting BBQ sauce on food is a far cry from real BBQ. Being from Kansas city I would like nothing more than for this place to be a great place to find good BBQ in Dayton now that I live here. Witho...
(07/23/2005)
How can you go wrong with this place? The BBQ chicken is outstanding and I've heard that the ribs are great as well. Not only that, but you get a lot of food for your money.
(05/07/2008)
I was raised in Dayton and come back ther about 4 times a year for various reasons. These trips always include ribs from old hickory. To me, they are the best after sampling many others. I only eat ribs from Hickory now.