P.J. Whelihan's

The long awaited PJs Medford Lakes is a great place to hang out with family and friends, watch the game, eat a great meal, enjoy happy hour drink specials, or celebrate a memorable event in a unique neighborhood pub and restaurant. We pride ourselves on outstanding food at a terrific value, a wide selection of bottle and draft beer and consistently friendly service.



This is our first totally new building, and we couldn't think of a better community to help us through the process than Medford Lakes.


The new PJ's Pub and Grille Room sits on the site of the former Settler's Inn, which was sadly lost in a fire in 1999. Since the Inn was considered one of the largest log structures in the United States, PJ Whelihan's Pub and Grille Room continues the log cabin tradition with its rustic wood-themed interior, rich fabrics, high-vaulted ceilings, stone fireplaces and a commanding view of Ballinger Lake across Stokes Road.



In all, PJ's Pub and Grille Room is an expansive, 9,000-square-foot restaurant, sitting on a 1.7-acre site at Stokes and Tabernacle roads. One of the great features at PJ Whelihan's Pub and Grille Room is the result of a great suggestion by the borough residents - our large, open area for dining.