Mitchell's Fish Market
Seafood · Carmel, IN
Seafood
Deals & ways to save
We don’t have a dining certificate or coupon for Mitchell's Fish Market in our current feed.
ActiveDiner may earn a commission when you buy through sponsored links on this page.
Diner reviews of Mitchell's Fish Market
A diner from Carmel, IN
Jul 16, 2008
We went to Mitchells and were extremely disapointed. When I opened my silverware, the forks had old food crusted to it. The server's name was J**** and she was the worst server I have ever had in my life. The food was cold and it all came out at the same time (appetizers, salad, dinner). I would not recommend this restaurant to my worst enemy!
A diner from Fishers, IN
Jan 27, 2008
Expensive for average food marketed as "fresh". One would hope so. Took forever to obtain a cocktail. French fries were lukewarm. Server was excellent when he finally showed up. This restaurant seems to be exploiting the expensive fish trend. I had a super cod fish fry for $12.95 at another place. Here it was $16.95.
A diner from Carmel, IN
Dec 28, 2007
We love Mitchell's. The food, servers, bar, etc is just perfect. A great place to eat!!!
A diner from Carmel, IN
Dec 28, 2006
We have gone to Mitchells approx. 5 times and every time we think we'll try the oyster bar and every time we are extremely disapointed. The main courses are wonderful - can't say enough about the quality of the seafood main courses but the raw oysters are absolutely terrible and we've tried them 5 times.
Write a review
Reviews of similar restaurants
The newest review from each of 6 other restaurants in Carmel.
-
Donatos Pizzeria - 106th & Michigan
Pizzeria
ActiveDiner diner
Apr 2, 2013
I work here and we have a mouse problem. I often find fecal matter throughout the restaurant. The manager encourages changing the dates on foods to save money and throws away pizzas that are perfectly edible instead of g
-
Baskin Robins Thirty-One Merchant Square
Ice Cream/Yogurt Shop
ActiveDiner diner
Jan 26, 2013
have gotten my daughter's birthday cake at BR for a couple decades - always the same - mint chocolate chip. Nothing that remarkable but she likes it. I understand the price increases. Everyone is facing the same press
-
China Garden
Chinese
No star rating
ActiveDiner diner
Jul 28, 2011
very very bad experience. i called for delivery order. person who took the order was very rude, did not listen to me at all. he said order will be delivered in 40 mins. after 80 mins(more than one hour) nobody delivered.
-
Zacky's Hot Dogs
Hot Dog
ActiveDiner diner
Apr 15, 2011
Awesome food. Zacky and family get to know you. It's a very fun experience.
-
Glass Chimney
Continental
ActiveDiner diner
Dec 12, 2010
Love, love, love this place! The bar special is $14.00 which includes a glass of wine or draft beer, and is a huge meal. They have a $30.00 special in the main dining room with a soup or salad, entree, and dessert! Th
-
Cancun Mexican Restaurant
Mexican
ActiveDiner diner
Feb 5, 2010
Food was excellent. Service was fast. I will definitely go there again
