Diner reviews of Dick & Joan's Supper Club
5★
21
4★
8
3★
2
2★
1
1★
4
A diner from Oshkosh, WI
Feb 10, 2013
We went on a Friday night. Their menu bar said 'limited' salad bar...well lettuce only with tomatoes and dressing was it! We spent $20 on a steak and it was a waste of $$$! Our waitress was wonderful, but what we paid for our entrees and after we saw the salad bar, this meal was far from acceptable. That was our first and last visit.
A diner from Appleton, WI
Aug 19, 2012
I just ate there with a friend Sunday. It was packed, but service was prompt. I don't know about fish or chicken, but the Prime Rib was perfect! Defininitely great steaks.
A diner from Greenville, WI
Aug 6, 2012
Food was great, staff was friendly, overall - great experience! We had to wait for a while at the bar, but that was just part of the experience... I would recommend!
A diner from Neenah, WI
Aug 5, 2012
Took my girlfriend out to dinner at Dick and Joan's last weekend, it was our first time there, my dad recommended it (he has been going for years). We each had awesome old fashions, got our order put in at the bar and got a table a half hour later. My date got a tenderloin and lobster special and I got prime rib and both dinners were fantastic. The price was very reasonable and we were very happy with the entire experience. The bartenders were laughing behind the bar with customers while giving great service, the waitress was awesome and very efficient. We will be back!
A diner from Appleton, WI
Aug 4, 2012
WOW! We have been coming to Dick and Joan's for years and we are always impressed with our experience... and yet we are amazed again by the amount of food we got, how delicious it was, and how affordable it was. We sat at table 8 and had a tenderloin for two, it came with two kinds of potatoes, some onion rings, and sauteed mushrooms. It was by far the best steak I have ever had, we always order it medium-rare and it was perfect. As always, Great Job Dick and Joans!!!
A diner from Grand Chute
Jul 25, 2012
Just had dinner there, ordered tenderloin for two medium well when we got it the tenderloin was WELL done we tried it and it tasted rancide so my wife spit it out in a napkin when the waitstaff came to the table we told her and she took it back to make another one. When we received the new one it was 3/4 of an inch thick and very chewy so we told the waitstaff and she said that they pound it down to get it more tender that is why a tenderloin is so thin and to make it more tender. When we went to pay the bill the bartender asked how everything was and we told her and she said thats to bad and took our money. When we were leaving there was a gentleman standing by the bar and I asked him if he was an owner because my wife knew Pat as the owner and he said yes so i told him and he said thats to bad and that they don't beat on their meat to tenderise it. A tenderloin 3/4 inch thick for $31.45 are ya nuts.
ActiveDiner diner
May 8, 2012
Every time we get to Appleton we make it a point to have dinner at Dick & Joan's. Love the tenderloin. Staff is extremly friendly and efficient. Prices are very reasonable.
A diner from Menasha, WI
Apr 15, 2012
Had dinner there this past Friday. They were super busy, but seemed to move us right along. The bartenders were friendly and helpful on how the procedure is. We had about a 45 min. wait. The food was unbelievable good. Was told about the perch and my friends were right. I will definitely go back there and tell others about it.
A diner from Crivitz, WI
Mar 8, 2012
Went to this restaurant in February with a group of people & the person who plans our outings always calls ahead to make sure they will have room for us. We were so squashed together we could hardly move our arms. Bartenders & wait staff very unfriendly & cost of lunch is expensive seeing you only I only got a sandwich & chips. Atmosphere is old & outdated & group behind us were very loud & after the meal, continued to stay at the tables & played dominoes. Will never go here again!
A diner from Neenah, WI
Feb 15, 2012
My fiance & I are big fans of this Supper Club! It is the Old Fashioned Club with Great food & Great Service. However, went there for a nice dinner for Valentines Day & his Birthday & had a Great Dinner but the very worst service we have ever had!
Our waitress was terrible! Not only did she never check to see is our dinner was OK, when we asked her for more warm bread she & I quote told us "If I get time I will put some in the oven" We were there on Wednesday the Day after Valentines Day and they were not busy!
Being in the Food Service business my whole life thank God I never worked with her and if I was the owner she wouldn't work for me!
Food was fantastic! Bartenders Pat & Allie were great! But when you spend $65 for a nice dinner you should get decent service also!
A diner from Menasha Wi
Sep 11, 2011
Steaks come with a seasoning that can be a bit overwhelming. Friday night salad bar is weak, Saturday is ok
A diner from Neenah, WI
May 19, 2011
WOW! What a surprise for us as avid diners at this Supper Club! We loved (past) experiences we have had and will be back but we wanted to share a dinner we had tonight! May 19th! Our service at the Bar was great! Abby you are one of a kind! We waited an hour for a waitress to take our order after we aked for a waitress. Not only was she not friendly but she was not very busy at the time! Our meal was the same as we always order and it was awful! We didn't even stay to eat it! We were so dissapointed in our service and food that we have decided to find another restaraunt to patronize every Thursday night to give them a chance! $75+ dollars plus a tip is worth our business but this time your restaraunt really did not make us happy at all!! Although we will be back because you have great food and service please take this as constuction critiism as it was not good by all means!!! Maybe its time you have a staff meeting to work on your customer service and quality & consistenty of your restaraunt!
A diner from Neenah, WI
Apr 30, 2011
Another wonderful experience at a local supper club! We can't say enough about the great food and staff at Dick & Joan's. We went just for a steak dinner out (Sirloin,Tenderloin & Crab) and everything about it was perfect!
It is the Old Fashioned Family Supper Club that we are very happy to still have in our community!!! Love it & will be enjoying & celebrating Mother's Day with all of you there!!!
Larry Ware & Mary Smith
A diner from Neenah, WI
Mar 11, 2011
Absolutely WONDERFUL super club experience! Dick and Joans is the best place in the Valley to get amazing fish frys on friday!! Their Clam Chowder is the BEST soup I have ever tasted in my LIFE!!! And besides the food, the bartenders and waitstaff are such friendly people! Keep up the good work guys n' gals!
A diner from Appleton, WI
Mar 9, 2011
We were hungry for some fish on Ash Wednesday so we looked for somewhere close to home. Being in WI I figured most places (especially supper clubs) would have a descent fish dinner. This was honestly the worst fish I have had at a restaurant in a long time. I would have been better off getting a fish sandwich at McDonalds then ordering their fish sandwich. My girlfriend ordered the perch plate and it was just as horrible. As an avid fisher I understand nothing is as good as fresh fish but this was an absolute disappointment. I will never eat their again and will make sure no one I know eats there either.
A diner from Neenah, WI
Mar 8, 2011
I took my in-laws out for a "supper club" experience last week and we ended up at Dick & Joan's as first time patrons. The meal was delicious, the waitress (Tabitha) and the kitchen staff were very friendly and professional and our experience was positive. I recommend the tenderloin and broiled shrimp, it was heavenly. My father-in-law liked his frog legs just as much. The only improvement we would of liked to have seen was a more upbeat and personable bartender, but I guess you can't ask for it all. We will be back!!
A diner from Neenah, WI
Jan 4, 2011
Once again a perfect dinner at Dick & Joan"s! Our comments to this experience were that our waitress was friendly but didn't seem to concerned with how we were doing & the portion of Crab (I had Crab/Tenderloin Combo) could have had a larger portion of Crab. Overall, The Best!We came home very satisfied and will be back!
A diner from Neenah, WI
Dec 27, 2010
Dick & Joans has the best Sirloin Steak in the whole Fox Valley! Being a chef and working in some of the finest establishments in Door County I have found that the food,service,price and atmosphere is amazing! Every year we receive a gift certificate for dinner from my mother for Christmas and once again we chose Dick & Joan's! Kepp up the good work! See you soon!!
Larry Ware & Mary Smith
A diner from Appleton WI
Sep 10, 2010
The best food in the valley. Love the hot bacon dressing and husband loves the garlic toast. Never had a bad meal here ever! Great drinks too. We normally ask for a waitress right as we order our first drink so we are assured a table when ready to eat, otherwise you will be at the bar quite a while! Wouldn't change a thing!!
A diner from Appleton
Sep 8, 2010
A step back in time - like 40 years! The decor was the first que that this was very outdated, basing popularity on reputation alone. Many came in after us, were seated first, even though we voiced 3 times that we were ready to order. As we were looking at other dining options for the night, a server finally came. Bartenders, rude and aloof, and the general atmosphere was like a place my parents took me in the late 60's.
Bathrooms - old
Dining room - old
Food - fair if you like the 'supper club' selection
Won't be back-
A diner from Fox Valley
Jul 9, 2010
We go to Dick and Joans often, very rare is a dinner not great. We have to ask for a waitress as some wear WAY to much perfume. (always hope the few overscented aren't waiting the table next to us)
Fresh bread, still warm makes every dinner great.
Hot bacon dressing, yum.
We aren't a fan of the small cove behind salad bar, but know of others who love it!
hungry now, think we will go for Friday fish...if we decide on a steak instead they will have that too.
A diner from Shiocton, WI
May 9, 2010
we go to dick and joans every sunday and carol is our waitress and she goes above and beyond to make sure we get the best service and best food in town.....cant say this about any other restaurant in appleton/greenbay area
A diner from Menasha, WI
May 6, 2010
Great place for lunch. Always great food. Never, ever been unhappy. So much better then all the chain restaurants.
A diner from Neenah, WI
Feb 27, 2010
Excellent food all the time. I wish there were onions on the Friday limited salad bar. Onions would be better then the pink out of season tomatoes.
A diner from Larsen, WI
Dec 27, 2009
The Best Supper Club to bring Family and friends,Wonderful drinks and food!!!If you dont like it here, you have bad tastebuds...
A diner from Little Chute, WI
Nov 13, 2009
Very disappointed. My fiance and I went here last weekend to try something different. The bartender was very rude and unfriendly. We asked if we could sit at the bar and look over menus until a waitress was ready. She grumbled that that was fine. We got a drink, which wasn't exactly as ordered, then we were ignored for ~45 minutes. Customers that came in and sat at the bar after us kept getting served, it was like we were invisible! We asked for a waitress again, and a "nicer" bartender said she would try to get one for us. A waitress shortly came out but again asked the people next to us for their order and ignored us! We gave up after about an hour and went home :( Never got to try the food. I wasn't too impressed with the menu to begin with as it was a Friday and apparently there are many items the don't serve on Fridays.
A diner from OAK FOREST IL
Aug 1, 2009
A must-stop when in Appleton. the food and sweet brady old fashions are the greatest. Keep up the great job!
A diner from Milwaukee, WI
Jul 9, 2009
A group of us from Milwaukee stop there every time we stay in Appleton for a Packer game. The food is a great value and the staff is fantastic. I highly recommend it to anyone passing through Appleton
A diner from Shiocton
May 25, 2009
Best liver and onions around!!
A diner from Chippewa Falls, WI
Aug 12, 2008
The food is the best around. The hot bacon german salad dressing is a must try. Great value. I live 150 miles away, but still eat there everytime I am in town!
A diner from appleton, WI
Jul 16, 2008
always happy with the food, great salad bar. So far its the best haddock in town I've had.
A diner from Appleton, WI
Apr 18, 2008
Fantastic food and Great service! Prices are cheap compared to other supper clubs. Highly recommend!
A diner from Neenah Wi
Nov 15, 2006
This restaurant has been my husband and my favorite for about 10 years. The service is always great and so is the food. My only gripe I hoped they would have changed by now is to have a kids menu.
A diner from Clintonville, WI
Oct 16, 2006
Very good!
A diner from Milwaukee area
Feb 4, 2006
Food has always been pretty good, some items better than others. Seafoods pretty good. Salmon patties medium.
A diner from Fort Atkinson, WI
Jun 9, 2003
Overall it was good, but the Clam Chowder was a great disappointment.
Great bar atmoshpere.
Write a review
