Indianapolis Restaurant Guide

Amici's Italian Restaurant
4.2 stars (3 ratings)

(317) 634-0440

601 East New York Street, Indianapolis, IN 46202

View Map

Dining Specials

Marker Restaurant
American, Italian
Edelweiss Restaurant
American, German, Banquet/Party Room, Bar Restaurant in
Indianapolis
5  out of 5 stars
5|The food is excellent. There is a German Buffet evry Wednesday that is outstanding. You have the o...

Italian Food & Culture History

June 6, 2005 @ 2:43 PM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from Indianapolis
The food is absolutely wonderful. Great friendly service. If you need a table they will do anything to get you in. We will eat here over and over again.
March 12, 2005 @ 2:59 PM
3  out of 5 stars
a diner from Ann Arbor, MI
The food (presentation and quality) was not worth the price. The seafood pasta ($15) had 3 small shrimp and a few scallops in it, with a bland sauce. The manicotti wasn't bad, but the sauce was slopped all over the side of the plate. We went here hoping for a romantic evening, and ended up sitting in a room with a family with noisy children, we were brought the wrong food, had a strange hostess, and when the right food arrived it wasn't particularly good. Not a place I will ever go again or recommend.

50% Off Dining Certificates at these locations...
5  out of 5 stars
Comfort Food/Home Cooking, Country Restaurant in
Indianapolis
4  out of 5 stars
Mediterranean, Middle Eastern, Turkish, Casual/Family Restaurant in
Indianapolis
2  out of 5 stars
Mexican, Casual/Family, Children's Menu, Early Bird Special Restaurant in
Indianapolis

Reviews of Similar Restaurants

American, European, Italian, Casual/Family
Though I have not physically been to Big Mikes, the food that was catered into our office was wonderful. I plan on checking out their lunch menu and going there myself. The delivery person was probably the nicest I have ever seen. Totally recommend ...
American, European, Italian, Casual/Family
Just left Big Mikes and it was fabulous. The food was delicious, staff was very nice and it has a very laid back and relaxing environment.This place is very affordable too! I would recommend if you havent tried it out yet.........Do it!!!
American, European, Italian, Casual/Family
Outstanding food and service! I eat there at least once a week.
American, European, Italian, Casual/Family
What a delightful dining experience. Professional servers who really make the experience wonderful. The paella was fantastic. The caprese salad was fresh and wonderful. The presentation of the food was beautiful. The grouper was unbelievable.
American, European, Italian, Casual/Family
Best lasagna I've ever had. Very cozy and quaint. Wait staff can be hit or miss, but it's always a personal experience. Both times I've been there the chef/owner has visited and chatted us up. A good "serious date" spot.

Read More: Indianapolis Restaurant Reviews

Avg Rating: 4  out of 5 stars

Number of Reviews: 3

June 6, 2005 @ 2:43 PM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from Indianapolis
The food is absolutely wonderful. Great friendly service. If you need a table they will do anything to get you in. We will eat here over and over again.
March 12, 2005 @ 2:59 PM
3  out of 5 stars
a diner from Ann Arbor, MI
The food (presentation and quality) was not worth the price. The seafood pasta ($15) had 3 small shrimp and a few scallops in it, with a bland sauce. The manicotti wasn't bad, but the sauce was slopped all over the side of the plate. We went here hoping for a romantic evening, and ended up sitting in a room with a family with noisy children, we were brought the wrong food, had a strange hostess, and when the right food arrived it wasn't particularly good. Not a place I will ever go again or recommend.
January 12, 2005 @ 11:02 PM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from Indianapolis, IN
This place is a jewel. In a world of upscale, this place is downscale and the food cozy and delicious. We had the manicotti which
they made out of thin crepes and filled with 3
cheeses. We loved the casual atmosphere with
local art on the walls. Our waitress recommended
the coffee ice cream...absolutely heaven! And the
best dirty martinis we have ever had! A great family-run business in a really cool historic building. We'll be back many times!
Read More Indianapolis Restaurant Reviews

Amici's Italian Restaurant Map

Recent Amici's Italian Restaurant Reviews

June 6, 2005 @ 2:43 PM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from Indianapolis
The food is absolutely wonderful. Great friendly service. If you need a table they will do anything to get you in. We will eat here over and over again.
March 12, 2005 @ 2:59 PM
3  out of 5 stars
a diner from Ann Arbor, MI
The food (presentation and quality) was not worth the price. The seafood pasta ($15) had 3 small shrimp and a few scallops in it, with a bland sauce. The manicotti wasn't bad, but the sauce was slopped all over the side of the plate. We went here hoping for a romantic evening, and ended up sitting in a room with a family with noisy children, we were brought the wrong food, had a strange hostess, and when the right food arrived it wasn't particularly good. Not a place I will ever go again or recommend.