follow us on twitter    Get ActiveDiner on the iPhone


All Restaurants
Prime Rib

Nearby Cities

West Palm Beach
Delray Beach
Lake Worth
Boynton Beach
North Palm Beach

Dining Specials

Gazebo Cafe
- French, Italian, Fine Dining, Banquet/Party Room
Le Metro Neighborhood Bistro at Abacoa
- Continental, French Restaurant in

3.7 stars (2 ratings)

Nick's Tomato Pie

(561) 744-8935
1697 West Indiantown Road, Jupiter, FL 33458 | MAP
  | Share |
Italian (Italian Food & Culture History)


Restaurant Description

Superb Dining, wonderful menu, excellent food and service

Recent Nick's Tomato Pie Reviews

A diner from Tequesta, FL gave an overall rating of 4  out of 5 stars on January 4, 2009 @ 4:58 PM

 I'm very surprised to read the prior review. We have been going there for years and never found Wendy or the staff to be anything but friendly and pleasant. Either Wendy had a rare off night or the other writer is hyper sensitive and should give the place another try.
A diner from Boca Raton, Florida gave an overall rating of 3  out of 5 stars on January 3, 2008 @ 12:39 PM

 I was very disappointed with the hostess staff on New Years Eve, 12/31/07. Wendy the hostess and as I understand the manager on duty was extremely rude. Her behavior affected my party's overall enjoyment of this festive evening. Upon arrival to the restaurant we were not greeted with a smile,a happy new year greeting or even a hello. I inquired as to the state of our seating and she advised that it would be at least a 25 minut wait. When I asked for clarification about the call in wait list another much younger hostess started to explain the procedure and Wendy immediately interrupted and stated "You don't have to explain it to her, the wait is 25 minutes here is your pager". I stated that she didn't have to be so apprupt and asked for her name. The hosting and wait at the hostess station was not very well coordinated and the two young girls assisting Wendy did not have a clue what was going on. I observed people being told the wait was 25 minuts only to come back after the stated time to be told it was another 25 minuts. One hostess was asked what the wait time was and she stated to a customer that she did not know. The customer and his party then left. The whole reception area function was grossly mismanged and Wendy's rudeness was not acceptable for such a festive evening. When I tried to explain my concerns to the owner I was advised that he does not have regular hours and that he comes and goes. Consequently it has been difficult to catch him at the restaurant to explain my concerns to him. I sure hope that customers who choose to go to Nick's Tomato Pie in the future have a much more pleasant greeting and overall experience than my party did.

50% Off Certificates at these locations...
Lighthouse Diner
American Restaurant in

Nippon Japanese Restaurant Sushi Bar & Hibachi Gri
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Casual/Family, Kids Friendly Restaurant in

4 Brothers Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
5  out of 5 stars
Italian Restaurant in
Delray Beach

  » See All Jupiter Restaurant Coupons & Deals


Reviews of Similar Restaurants

Trattoria Delfino Inc  1  out of 5 stars
Italian, Pizzeria
 Ordered dinner at this restaurant and it was terrible. What I received I would have expected from a pizza joint. Their prices were insane, the preparation of the food was what you would expect from a diner. I would not visit this place again, nor rec ...
Trattoria Delfino Inc  4  out of 5 stars
Italian, Pizzeria
 Very good food and Fantastic Opera nights. I feal luky that The singing is even better than what you hear at met Today. Thank you Delfino.
Buonasera  5  out of 5 stars
Italian, Pizzeria
 The food was excellent, I had snapper and my husband had the scallops. Both were delicious with subtle flavors which highlighted a talented chef. We split the salad with beets, apples, et al. and the presentation was lovely, and very tasty. We went t ...
Trattoria Delfino Inc  5  out of 5 stars
Italian, Pizzeria
 We have been coming here for years and it is always the best!
Zipzs Ny Pizza & Italian  5  out of 5 stars
Italian, Pizzeria
 Zipz's has the best pizza in Jupiter. Also really good classic Italian dishes made from scratch. Great find.

  » Read More: Jupiter Restaurant Reviews