follow us on twitter    Get ActiveDiner on the iPhone


All Restaurants
New American

Nearby Cities

Winter Park
Altamonte Springs

Dining Specials

Café Trastevere
- Italian, Casual/Family, Outdoor Seating, Romantic
5  out of 5 stars
5|Firstly, the beauty inside and the surrounding gardens make up for any naturally occuring, yet ine...
Cala Bella Shingle Creek
- American, Italian, Japanese, Mediterranean

5 stars (1 ratings)

Lil Anthony's N.Y. Pizzeria

(407) 737-7499
425 South Avalon Park Blvd., Orlando, FL 32828 | MAP
  | Share |
Italian, Pizzeria, Casual/Family, Catering, Delivery, Kids Friendly, Smoking/Non Smoking, Take Out/Carry Out, TV/Satellite, Dinner, Lunch (Italian Food & Culture History)


Restaurant Description

Although the choices are many for authentic New York pizza in Orlando, Lil Anthony's N.Y. Pizzeria pride themselves on using high-quality ingredients while cooking in the traditional New York way. Lil Anthony's offers more than just pizza: they serve wings, salads, specialty calzones, hot subs, and other Italian favorites. Popular pizza flavors include: the Mediterranean, topped with olives, spinach, garlic, broccoli, tomatoes, and green peppers; or the Bianca, layered with mozzarella, ricotta, parmigiana, and garlic. Although the prices aren't comparable to national pizza chains, you'll get better quality and stellar service at Lil Anthony's N.Y. Pizzeria.

Recent Lil Anthony's N.Y. Pizzeria Reviews

A diner from Chicago, IL gave an overall rating of 5  out of 5 stars on February 18, 2012 @ 9:39 PM

 The closest you can get to authentic New York pizza in Orlando!

There’s no pizza quite like the pizza you can get in New York City, and that’s not likely to change anytime soon, but Lil Anthony’s is just about the closest I’ve tasted outside of New York. The buffalo wings and meatballs are delicious, but the pizza is really what sets it above almost any other restaurant in the city. The atmosphere is great, the service is excellent and the food is absolutely tremendous. I highly recommend giving it at least one visit.

50% Off Certificates at these locations...
Italian Village Pizza
4  out of 5 stars
Italian, Delivery, Kids Friendly, Late Night Dining
  » See All Orlando Restaurant Coupons & Deals


Reviews of Similar Restaurants

Chuck E Cheese's - Orlando  5  out of 5 stars
 every family knows this place is here to stay for children's birthday celebrations. Enjoy!
Fresco's Fine Italian Dining  5  out of 5 stars
 a wonderful family owned restaurant in a casual atmosphere with friendly service and outstanding food . Love this place!
Carrino's Italian Restaurant Pizza & Del  2  out of 5 stars
 sorry to report out of business .
Fresco's Fine Italian Dining  5  out of 5 stars
 Your food is freshly prepared and delivered to your table with a happy smiling face and a big-ENJOY! NOW that's ITALIAN!
Stoney's Restaurant @ Stoneybrook Golf Club  1  out of 5 stars
 Went on December 30th for anniversary dinner with 6 guests total. Made reservations ahead of time for 7 PM We all ordered 12oz sirloin steaks with broccoli which is the most expensive menu item. Came out and said they only had 3 sirloin steaks lef ...

  » Read More: Orlando Restaurant Reviews