New Hartford Restaurant Reviews
Welcome to our New Hartford restaurant reviews guide where you'll find top restaurants off the beaten path, both locally owned and chain. In fact, some of the best restaurants in the New Hartford just might be the little mom and pop operations flying under the radar. For some of the best picks in New Hartford, you've come to the right place.
Our New Hartford restaurant reviews guide can help you make sense of the thousands of options out there. Happy eating!
Also check out our Best Restaurants in New Hartford 2016 Guide
“The food is great here, but the restaurant itself is old, dank and dark. You should just pick up your food here, but not dine in. They should really remodel because everyone enjoys to visit a pizza parlor often!” (03/11/2008)
“Chatterly's is a cute bar and restaurant, reminds me of the neighborhood pub! The food was excellent! We shared the salad with the homemade buttermilk dressing, excellent! I always get the pasta with spicy shrimp and scallops, excellent! They don't give many scallops or shrimp, but it was still ... ” (02/04/2008)
“My husband and I passed through New Hartford the first weekend in February 2008. We stopped for a coffee break, and decided to order lunch instead. A bit confusing when you come in, on whether to seat yourself or not - finally caught a waitress's eye, and got the message to seat ourselves. We got ... ” (02/12/2005)
“Food, service and atmosphere are outstanding. High end food without the high end price. You won't find better in the surrounding areas including Hartford.” (11/10/2000)
“Sandwich shop that builds very good sandwiches from standard ingredients in a typical chain store setting. Prices are excellent when you use the coupons!” (11/10/2000)
“Pizza and salad both mediocre, sauce was tasteless. Looks depressing and rundown inside, no reason to want to return here.” (11/10/2000)
“Pizza was excellent in comparison with old managment. Service varied from excellent to slow, understaffed. Wood rate it as a decent Pizza place for the family.” (11/10/2000)
“Lunch menu was diversified, prices were on target, service efficient but hurried, food was very good.”