Newburgh Restaurant Guide

Costagliolas Ltl Italy Restaurant
4.6 stars (7 ratings)

(845) 565-1515

121 Washington Ter, Newburgh, NY 12550

View Map

Dining Specials

A and S Deli
American, Deli/Sandwich/Subs, Fast Food Restaurant in
Newburgh
Fish and Chikzz
American Restaurant in
Newburgh

Reviews of Similar Restaurants

If I could rate this with 1/4 of a star I would! For my birthday I got a gift certificate to a Cena 2000. We had never been and were really looking...
Huge portions, delicious sandwiches. Don't know where they come up with some of the combination's but they work. Breakfast is the quickest and tastie...
Great Service Great Food Great People Great Location What else can you ask for!
Noto's Deli in Newburgh : This is Manny. I want to tell you guys how appreciative I am of your having my subs and Doritos and beverages all ready ...
Too bad there was not a .0001 star rating. That might be more appropriate. Went on a Sat. evening June 08, they were busy. We allegedly had reservatio...

Italian Food & Culture History

February 5, 2014 @ 9:37 PM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from Port Jervis
The food is delicious. It is real Italian food . The tomato sauce is not bitter or acidic , but , just right. The service was excellent. I would recommend this restaurant to those who enjoy good food and a friendly environment.
January 3, 2010 @ 1:52 AM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from Toms River, NJ
Met some family from upstate NY there about halfway from our home in NJ. Excellent food and quick service, but not rushed at all. Four of us had meals from the lunch specials menu - value priced, still large portions, but smaller portions than their dinner menu they told us. Fish was fresh, cooked perfectly, pasta was not overdone. Salads were crisp with a nice house vinaigrette, fresh bread on the table. We were happy to have found such a great place tucked away someplace where it would be easy to miss. Easy on/off access from I-87 and I-84, plenty of parking.

50% Off Dining Certificates at these locations...
Caribbean Restaurant in
Newburgh
American Restaurant in
Newburgh

Avg Rating: 5  out of 5 stars

Number of Reviews: 7

February 5, 2014 @ 9:37 PM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from Port Jervis
The food is delicious. It is real Italian food . The tomato sauce is not bitter or acidic , but , just right. The service was excellent. I would recommend this restaurant to those who enjoy good food and a friendly environment.
January 3, 2010 @ 1:52 AM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from Toms River, NJ
Met some family from upstate NY there about halfway from our home in NJ. Excellent food and quick service, but not rushed at all. Four of us had meals from the lunch specials menu - value priced, still large portions, but smaller portions than their dinner menu they told us. Fish was fresh, cooked perfectly, pasta was not overdone. Salads were crisp with a nice house vinaigrette, fresh bread on the table. We were happy to have found such a great place tucked away someplace where it would be easy to miss. Easy on/off access from I-87 and I-84, plenty of parking.
August 12, 2009 @ 4:45 PM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from The Poconos, Pennsylvania
My son and his girl friend drove from Albany to meet me and my younger son for a late lunch. I live in the Poconos and it was certainly worth the trip! We were greeted immediately by a friendly waitress and were seated promptly. We each had a salad and shared a jumbo shrimp cocktail which was excellent. The chicken parmesan and lasagna parmesan were delicious and authentic Italian cooking. The portions were huge (we each had a doggie bag to take home!). The tiramisu was heavenly and one serving is enough for two people! I could go on but I'm sure you get the idea -- this place is well worth your time and money if you love authentic Italian cooking. The only thing I would suggest is that they play music to add to the authentic and friendly atmosphere.
October 13, 2008 @ 11:22 AM
4  out of 5 stars
a diner from Somerset, Pa.
The food was good. The portions were large, you'll need a big appetite.
February 11, 2008 @ 12:58 PM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from milford, pa
WE HAVE BEEN DINING HERE APX 8 YRS AND THE FOOD NEVER CEASES TO AMAZE US FAMILY MEMBERS MAN THE KITCHEN LIKE NO OTHER AUTHENTIC ITALIAN DISHES FRESHEST INGREDIENTS OVERALL CASUAL FRIENDLY ATMOSPHERE ITALIAN FOOD LIKE GRAMA MADE!!! YOULL BECOME A REGULAR JUST LIKE WE DID WE LOVE IT!THEY ARE A VERY TOUGH ACT TO FOLLOW FOR TASTE OVERALL AND PLENTIFULNESS YOU WILL NOT LEAVE HUNGRY HOMEMADE TIRAMESU IS ONE OF OUR FAVORITE DESSERTS THE CALAMARI IS TENDER YET HAS A WONDERFUL CRISPNINESS TO IT THEIR PASTA SAUCE IS JUST LIKE YOUR GRANDMOTHER IS COOKING ON A SUNDAY ALWAYS WORTH THE RIDE FOR US AND WE HAVE COME TO KNOW THE FAMILY OVER THE YEARS THEY ARE ALL HARD WORKING AND COMMITTED TO SERVING THEIR CUSTOMERS THE BEST FOOD POSSIBLE THEY CONSIDER MANY OF THEIR REGULARS FAMILY AND WE CONSIDER THEM NUMERO ONO IN OUR BOOK OF FAVORITE ITALIAN RESTAURANTS!!!!!
February 15, 2007 @ 9:43 PM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from Gardiner, NY
The food is excellent and plentiful. The menu is extensive, so you can get anything you desire. The price is very reasonable, especially for the amount and quality of the food. The place is low-key and casual - not much ambience, but a nice place to go for a great meal without spending a lot of money.
June 23, 2005 @ 10:39 AM
4  out of 5 stars
a diner from Bear Mountain, NY
Food is excellent, Warm and friendly atmosphere although the room is too small and a little cramped. With a new room being built, I hope they redo the entire restaurant and make it one of the finest Italian restaurants in the area.
Read More Newburgh Restaurant Reviews

Costagliolas Ltl Italy Restaurant Map

Recent Costagliolas Ltl Italy Restaurant Reviews

February 5, 2014 @ 9:37 PM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from Port Jervis
The food is delicious. It is real Italian food . The tomato sauce is not bitter or acidic , but , just right. The service was excellent. I would recommend this restaurant to those who enjoy good food and a friendly environment.
January 3, 2010 @ 1:52 AM
5  out of 5 stars
a diner from Toms River, NJ
Met some family from upstate NY there about halfway from our home in NJ. Excellent food and quick service, but not rushed at all. Four of us had meals from the lunch specials menu - value priced, still large portions, but smaller portions than their dinner menu they told us. Fish was fresh, cooked perfectly, pasta was not overdone. Salads were crisp with a nice house vinaigrette, fresh bread on the table. We were happy to have found such a great place tucked away someplace where it would be easy to miss. Easy on/off access from I-87 and I-84, plenty of parking.