New York Restaurant Guide

Boxers
3.4 stars (2 ratings)

(212) 633-2275

190 W 4th St, New York, NY 10014

View Map

Dining Specials

Miss Mamie's Spoonbread Too
American, Soul Food, Southern, Barbecue
Russian Samovar
European, Russian, Casual/Family, Banquet/Party Room Restaurant in
New York
5  out of 5 stars
5|Great place, great food and sevice. Must see entertainment. The best infused vodkas. Oldest Russia...

May 14, 2006 @ 2:57 PM
1  out of 5 stars
a diner from New York, NY
This has one of the most bafflingly rude servers I have ever experienced who should be avoided at all cost.

Three friends and I ordered drinks from the bar and then decided we wanted to grab a snack, so we sat down for table service. We flagged the waiter and ordered fries, at which point, he says, sarcastically, "Wanna order that from the bar?" before ripping the menus out of our hands.

Um okay. So then we ordered fries from the bar. But shortly after, he came back with a plate of fries. Huh? Why did he tell us to order at the bar if he was going to serve us anyway? But then, the bartender we had ordered from brings over another plate of fries the one that we had ordered from the bar!

We were thoroughly confused. He rudely told us to order fries from the bar, so we did, but then he took our order anyway, so now we had an extra plate of fries, and he expected us to pay for both!

Okay, I know it's standard for places to require a $10 minimum for table service and the fries were only $5, but how about simply letting us know that Boxer's was such a place instead of being rude about it? And how about letting us know that youre actually putting in our order? It wouldve taken one simple little sentence. Even if he had just told us the info in a rude tone, it would have been no big deal.

But that kind of attitude is unacceptable. And I'm saying this from the point of view of someone who has worked in food service for several years at extremely busy places. I'm usually very sympathetic to people in food service. I understand how hard it can be and how annoying it is to have to repeat the same thing twenty thousand times, but you know what? You still say it!
4  out of 5 stars
a diner from Oklahoma
I was in town for the dog show so of course we came to this restaurant! I loved the whole concept of the place! And seeing the pictures on the walls and actually knowing the dogs was pretty cool too. I love the tee shirts and boxers and stuffed boxer dogs! It was really cool!

50% Off Dining Certificates at these locations...
4  out of 5 stars
Indian, Indian/Pakistan, Ethnic Setting, Casual/Family Restaurant in
New York
3  out of 5 stars
Italian, Northern Italian Restaurant in
New York
3  out of 5 stars
Middle Eastern, Hookah Bar Restaurant in
New York

Reviews of Similar Restaurants

Caribbean, Barbecue
I have been eating at Virgil's for at least 7 years and I have never had a bad experience! The food is terrific and the drinks will hit you like a ton of bricks! The "Fall Off The Porch Long Island Iced Tea" is the best drink that I have ever had i ...
Caribbean, Barbecue
great food, people time
Caribbean, Barbecue
GREAT FOOD IS ALL I CAN SAY.
Caribbean, Barbecue
BARBECUE, this is the one word to describe the smoky, tangy, saucy utterances that issue from MoBay Uptown's kitchen. I had gone many times before, for the whole snapper rundown, the crab cakes and the fabulous vegetarian offerings, but once I taste ...
Caribbean, Barbecue
I am a Jamaican and let me say that this particualr Golden Crust SUCKS!!!!! BIG time!The food there is horrible. The curry goat is always salt and their oxtail is undone. the onlty thing i buy is the mild patty or the banana chips because I like them ...

Read More: New York Restaurant Reviews

Avg Rating: 3  out of 5 stars

Number of Reviews: 2

May 14, 2006 @ 2:57 PM
1  out of 5 stars
a diner from New York, NY
This has one of the most bafflingly rude servers I have ever experienced who should be avoided at all cost.

Three friends and I ordered drinks from the bar and then decided we wanted to grab a snack, so we sat down for table service. We flagged the waiter and ordered fries, at which point, he says, sarcastically, "Wanna order that from the bar?" before ripping the menus out of our hands.

Um okay. So then we ordered fries from the bar. But shortly after, he came back with a plate of fries. Huh? Why did he tell us to order at the bar if he was going to serve us anyway? But then, the bartender we had ordered from brings over another plate of fries the one that we had ordered from the bar!

We were thoroughly confused. He rudely told us to order fries from the bar, so we did, but then he took our order anyway, so now we had an extra plate of fries, and he expected us to pay for both!

Okay, I know it's standard for places to require a $10 minimum for table service and the fries were only $5, but how about simply letting us know that Boxer's was such a place instead of being rude about it? And how about letting us know that youre actually putting in our order? It wouldve taken one simple little sentence. Even if he had just told us the info in a rude tone, it would have been no big deal.

But that kind of attitude is unacceptable. And I'm saying this from the point of view of someone who has worked in food service for several years at extremely busy places. I'm usually very sympathetic to people in food service. I understand how hard it can be and how annoying it is to have to repeat the same thing twenty thousand times, but you know what? You still say it!
4  out of 5 stars
a diner from Oklahoma
I was in town for the dog show so of course we came to this restaurant! I loved the whole concept of the place! And seeing the pictures on the walls and actually knowing the dogs was pretty cool too. I love the tee shirts and boxers and stuffed boxer dogs! It was really cool!
Read More New York Restaurant Reviews

Boxers Map

Recent Boxers Reviews

May 14, 2006 @ 2:57 PM
1  out of 5 stars
a diner from New York, NY
This has one of the most bafflingly rude servers I have ever experienced who should be avoided at all cost.

Three friends and I ordered drinks from the bar and then decided we wanted to grab a snack, so we sat down for table service. We flagged the waiter and ordered fries, at which point, he says, sarcastically, "Wanna order that from the bar?" before ripping the menus out of our hands.

Um okay. So then we ordered fries from the bar. But shortly after, he came back with a plate of fries. Huh? Why did he tell us to order at the bar if he was going to serve us anyway? But then, the bartender we had ordered from brings over another plate of fries the one that we had ordered from the bar!

We were thoroughly confused. He rudely told us to order fries from the bar, so we did, but then he took our order anyway, so now we had an extra plate of fries, and he expected us to pay for both!

Okay, I know it's standard for places to require a $10 minimum for table service and the fries were only $5, but how about simply letting us know that Boxer's was such a place instead of being rude about it? And how about letting us know that youre actually putting in our order? It wouldve taken one simple little sentence. Even if he had just told us the info in a rude tone, it would have been no big deal.

But that kind of attitude is unacceptable. And I'm saying this from the point of view of someone who has worked in food service for several years at extremely busy places. I'm usually very sympathetic to people in food service. I understand how hard it can be and how annoying it is to have to repeat the same thing twenty thousand times, but you know what? You still say it!
4  out of 5 stars
a diner from Oklahoma
I was in town for the dog show so of course we came to this restaurant! I loved the whole concept of the place! And seeing the pictures on the walls and actually knowing the dogs was pretty cool too. I love the tee shirts and boxers and stuffed boxer dogs! It was really cool!